| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| John Harkness HARV1st | DEC | Ross Shaffer PSU2nd |
| Consolation | ||
| Len Muldoon COLU | — | Howard Peters |
| Ross Shaffer PSU | PIN 4:23 | Charles Small LEH |
| Charles Small LEH | PIN 7:35 | Len Muldoon COLU |
| Charles Small LEH | DEC | Robert Clarke YALE |
| Semifinal | ||
| John Harkness HARV | DEC | Charles Small LEH |
| Ross Shaffer PSU | DEC | Howard Peters CUSE |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Howard Peters CUSE | PIN 8:30 | Bill Leavitt COR |
| Ross Shaffer PSU | PIN 5:08 | Len Muldoon COLU |
| Charles Small LEH | PIN 6:34 | Bill Lange PENN |
| John Harkness HARV | DEC | Robert Clarke YALE |
| Pigtail | ||
| Howard Peters CUSE | PIN 10:00 | Hendee Smith PRIN |