| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 32 | ||
| Art Shelly CUSE | PIN 7:50 | Dave Wilmer PRIN |
| Bill Haydock PENN | PIN 7:52 | Neilson Beard Dartmouth College |
| Norm Hascall YALE | UNVERIFIED | Phil Conserva COLU |
| Leo Noker | ||
| UNVERIFIED 7-2 |
| George Rynick United States Coast Guard Academy |
| Joe Burns LEH | PIN 3:53 | Bernard Norton UVA |
| Fred Trake HARV | UNVERIFIED 8-4 | Ed Robertson ARMY |