| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 32 | ||
| John Boyd PENN | PIN 12:37 | Lucious Biglow YALE |
| Wallace Chambers PSU | UNVERIFIED | Henry Settle NAVY |
| Alan Packer ARMY | PIN | Jack Smith United States Coast Guard Academy |
| Frank Horvath | ||
| UNVERIFIED 6-5 |
| James Howard HARV |
| Clayton Birdsall Dartmouth College | UNVERIFIED 6-0 | John Wilkinson COR |