| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| Robert Schell FM1st | DEC 4-3 | Pilgrim McRaven LEH2nd |
| Semifinal | ||
| Robert Schell FM | PIN | Bob Valle CUSE |
| Pilgrim McRaven LEH |
| DEC 5-4 |
| George Hastings YALE |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Robert Schell FM | PIN 3:27 | Walter Powell PENN |
| George Hastings YALE | PIN | Charles Hall PRIN |
| Bob Valle CUSE | DEC 8-3 | George Schautz PSU |
| Pilgrim McRaven LEH | DEC 8-1 | Sam Nicholson ARMY |
| Round of 16 | ||
| Charles Hall PRIN | DEC | Joe Pettinato COLU |
| Robert Schell FM | PIN 2:53 | Jim Vovakes TEMPLE |
| Sam Nicholson ARMY | PIN 2:42 | George Johnson Dartmouth College |
| Walter Powell PENN | DEC 2-0 | David Coombs HARV |
| George Schautz PSU | DEC 3-1 | Howard Edwards NAVY |
| Bob Valle CUSE | DEC 5-2 | Richard Ferenbach BRWN |
| Pilgrim McRaven LEH | DEC 8-5 | William Morse UVA |
| George Hastings YALE | DEC 8-5 | Dan Cadiz COR |