| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 16 | ||
| Joe Lemyre PSU | PIN 3:33 | Bill Marchio FM |
| Gerry Tebben ARMY | PIN 7:30 | Charles Scudder RU |
| Joe Gattuso | ||
| PIN 8:23 |
| Calton MacDonald PRIN |
| John Kousi YALE | DEC 9-4 | Jack Platt LEH |
| Don Dickason COR | DEC 10-4 | Robert Sherry COLU |
| Mebane Turner UVA | DEC 8-3 | Joe Hubbard HARV |
| Henry Gobetz CUSE | DEC 9-2 | Russell Down PENN |