| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| Bill Hulings PITT1st | DEC 2-1 | Gene D'Alessandro RU2nd |
| Medal Round | ||
| Sid Nodland | ||
| DEC 7-0 |
| Tom Deppe LEH4th |
| Semifinal | ||
| Ed Peery PITT | DEC 2-0 | Bob Homan PSU |
| Bill Hulings PITT | DEC 2-1 | Gene D'Alessandro RU |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Gene D'Alessandro RU | PIN 5:45 | Tom Deppe LEH |
| Bill Hulings PITT | DEC 2-1 | Sid Nodland PSU |
| Ed Peery PITT | DEC 9-4 | Deane Oliver RU |
| Bob Homan PSU | MAJ DEC 9-0 | Parker Mangus LEH |
| Round of 16 | ||
| Tom Deppe LEH | PIN 4:43 | Bob Theriault YALE |
| Bill Hulings PITT | PIN 5:52 | John Buchanan COLU |
| Ed Peery PITT | PIN 7:04 | Dick Samuels FM |
| Deane Oliver RU | PIN 8:23 | Charles Gratto COR |
| Bob Homan PSU | PIN 8:16 | David Kline PENN |
| Gene D'Alessandro RU | DEC 8-3 | Don Clark CUSE |
| Sid Nodland PSU | DEC 9-4 | Bill Jemison COR |
| Parker Mangus LEH | DEC 5-0 | Phil Burnaman HARV |
| Round of 32 | ||
| Gene D'Alessandro RU | PIN 3:17 | Gil Bergendahl PRIN |
| Tom Deppe LEH | PIN 1:10 | Ben Waller ARMY |
| Bill Jemison COR | PIN 2:10 | Art McCall TEMPLE |
| Bill Hulings PITT | PIN 4:08 | John Baird BRWN |
| Deane Oliver RU | PIN 5:08 | Ivan Wolinsky NAVY |
| Bob Homan PSU | PIN 4:15 | Charles Root CUSE |
| Don Clark CUSE | DEC 9-3 | Ed Keating HARV |
| Sid Nodland PSU | DEC 5-0 | Leo Sheehan NAVY |
| John Buchanan COLU | DEC 4-3 | George Evans PENN |
| David Kline PENN | DEC 5-0 | John Snyder BRWN |
| Bob Theriault YALE | DEC 2-1 | Gerry Yoder FM |
| Dick Samuels FM | DEC 5-0 | Otis Graham YALE |
| Charles Gratto COR | DEFAULT | J.W. Woodmansee ARMY |
| Parker Mangus LEH | DEC 5-2 | Harold Powell COLU |
| Ed Peery PITT | DEC 10-4 | Mindy Peale PRIN |