| DEC 11-5 |
| Steve Traylor YALE2nd |
| Medal Round | ||
| Casper Tortella Wilkes University5th | DEC 6-4 | Gene Nighman COR4th |
| Casper Tortella Wilkes University5th | DEC 2-1 | Tony Surage RU6th |
| Consi Semi | ||
| Denny Reed LEH | DEC 8-4 | Casper Tortella Wilkes University |
| Gene Nighman COR | — | Tony Surage RU |
| Semifinal | ||
| Steve Traylor YALE | DEC 4-3 | Tony Surage RU |
| Doug Parise TEMPLE | DEC 11-4 | Denny Reed LEH |
| Consi 4 | ||
| Gene Nighman COR | DEC 7-2 | Tim Catalfo CUSE |
| Casper Tortella Wilkes University | DEC 6-4 | Galen McWilliams East Stroudsburg University |
| Consi 8 #2 | ||
| Casper Tortella Wilkes University | DEC 8-4 | Alex Montgomery HARV |
| Tim Catalfo CUSE | PIN 2:58 | Brian Roberts Colgate University |
| Gene Nighman COR | DEFAULT | Bob Jaeckel COLU |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Gene Nighman COR | DEC 8-2 | Tim Catalfo CUSE |
| Casper Tortella Wilkes University | MAJ DEC 18-9 | Bob Jaeckel COLU |
| Consi 8 #1 | ||
| Bob Jaeckel COLU | PIN 2:38 | Dave Hernley FM |
| Alex Montgomery HARV | — | Hal Fullmer PENN |
| Round of 16 | ||
| Denny Reed LEH | DEC 7-3 | Tim Catalfo CUSE |
| Steve Traylor YALE | DEC 6-6 | Bob Trombadore NAVY |
| Tony Surage RU | DEC 7-3 | Casper Tortella Wilkes University |
| Doug Parise TEMPLE | DEC 8-1 | Gene Nighman COR |
| Round of 32 | ||
| Denny Reed LEH | PIN 4:50 | Alex Montgomery HARV |
| Steve Traylor YALE | DEC 5-2 | Bob Jaeckel COLU |
| Doug Parise TEMPLE | DEFAULT 0:20 | Galen McWilliams East Stroudsburg University |
| Tim Catalfo CUSE | DEFAULT 6:07 | Hal Fullmer PENN |
| Casper Tortella Wilkes University | MAJ DEC 19-6 | Brian Roberts Colgate University |
| Bob Trombadore NAVY | DEC 9-2 | Dave Hernley FM |
| Gene Nighman COR | MAJ DEC 17-3 | Dave McDonald ARMY |
| Tony Surage RU | DEC 4-1 | Dave Trombadore PRIN |
