| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| Gene Mills CUSE1st | PIN 5:20 | |
| Medal Round | ||
| Ray Broughman W&M3rd | DEC 5-2 | Jim Abbott Colgate University4th |
| Guy Zanti NAVY5th | DEC 6-4 | Bob Turner ARMY6th |
| Consi Semi | ||
| Ray Broughman W&M | DEC 4-0 | Larry Kane COLU |
| Semifinal | ||
| Gene Mills CUSE | PIN 2:13 | Jim Abbott Colgate University |
| Bobby Weaver LEH | DEC 5-2 | Ray Broughman W&M |
| Consi 4 | ||
| Ray Broughman W&M | DEC 5-2 | Vince Desiderio East Stroudsburg University |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Bob Turner ARMY | MAJ DEC 10-2 | Mark Harbold COR |
| Guy Zanti NAVY | MAJ DEC 11-2 | Lou Hamer PENN |
| Round of 16 | ||
| Bobby Weaver LEH | PIN 1:59 | Mark Harbold COR |
| Gene Mills CUSE | PIN 2:24 | Doug Billig Wilkes University |
| Ray Broughman W&M | DEC 8-1 | Rick Beller HARV |
| Jim Abbott Colgate University | DEC 5-5 | Guy Zanti NAVY |
| Round of 32 | ||
| Gene Mills CUSE | PIN 2:51 | Lou Hamer PENN |
| Bobby Weaver LEH | PIN 0:57 | Larry Kane COLU |
| Doug Billig Wilkes University | PIN 4:23 | Pete DeVlaminck PRIN |
| Rick Beller HARV | PIN 3:47 | Vince Desiderio East Stroudsburg University |
| Jim Abbott Colgate University | DEC 10-5 | Dave Malles FM |
| Ray Broughman W&M | DEC 8-5 | Bob Turner ARMY |