| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 16 | ||
| Mark McLaughlin W&M | ||
| PIN 1:01 |
| Frank Castano Wilkes University |
| Darren Schulman CUSE | PIN 4:45 | Riley Nelson YALE |
| Terry Barry East Stroudsburg University | PIN 6:05 | Mark Vandermyde HARV |
| Pat Waters COR | PIN 3:39 | Lee Allman PENN |
| Scott Becker RU | DEC 7-5 | Jeff Butler ARMY |
| Nick Gross FM | DEC 5-4 | Kirk Salvo BRWN |
| Trevor Lewis PRIN | DEC 1-1 | Aaron Peters NAVY |