| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|
| Consolation | ||
| Mark Bybee NW | PIN 1:34 | Cody Bush CMU |
| Jamie Hensch UNCG | PIN 0:14 | Austin Palmer VMI |
| Mark Bybee NW | PIN 1:07 | Jamie Hensch UNCG |
| Pat Catarello ASU | DEC 8-1 | Dave Smith Lincoln College |
| William Hill MSU | DEC 3-2 | Ryan Cunningham CMU |
| Jeremy Fetty Manchester University | PIN 2:57 | John Sears ILL |
| William Hill MSU | MAJ DEC 8-0 | Shane Cross STAN |
| William Hill MSU | DEC 5-2 | Joe Tucceri COR |
| Shawn O'Rourke UO | DEC 6-4 | John Groundwater ASU |
| Ben King ILL | DEC 5-3 | Mark Lane Montana State - Northern |
| Jason Townsend HOF | PIN 3:47 | Mark Dufresne LEH |
| Josh Smith Cleveland State University | DEC 3-1 | Ryan Stonitsch NIU |
| Josh Smith Cleveland State University | DEC 2-1 | Scott Duffy ISU |
| B.J. Friedrichs Minnesota-Morris | DEC 6-4 | Ian Nelms CSUB |
| Josh Koscheck EDIN | DEC 7-1 | Josh Smith Cleveland State University |
| Leo Giel RIDER | DEC 4-2 | Nick Mengerink PITT |
| Mark Bybee NW | DEFAULT | Jason Moaney CLAR |
| Jamie Hensch UNCG | DEC 6-5 | Mike Feeney EMU |
| Mark Bybee NW | DEC 7-2 | Gabe McMahan IOWA |
| William Hill MSU | PIN 5:26 | Pat Catarello ASU |
| Jeremy Fetty Manchester University | DEC 12-11 | Jesse Culp UO |
| William Hill MSU | DEC 11-8 | Jeremy Fetty Manchester University |
| William Hill MSU | PIN 5:38 | Mark Bybee NW |
| John Groundwater ASU | DEC 9-2 | Jason Bellis BUCK |
| Mark Dufresne LEH | DEC 4-1 | Shawn O'Rourke UO |
| Jason Townsend HOF | DEC 8-4 | Ben King ILL |
| Nick Mengerink PITT | FORFEIT | Jason Townsend HOF |
| Josh Smith Cleveland State University | DEC 6-3 | Ryan Slack PENN |
| B.J. Friedrichs Minnesota-Morris | DEC 3-0 | Lewis Taylor Lassen College |
| Josh Smith Cleveland State University | DEC 3-1 | B.J. Friedrichs Minnesota-Morris |
| Nick Mengerink PITT | DEC 1-0 | Josh Koscheck EDIN |