| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Consolation |
| Kevin Keeney UO | PIN 5:13 | Barrett Cervetto Montclair State University |
| Damon Davis NIU | DEC 6-5 | Dan Griffith ISU |
| Matt Lamb MSU | DEFAULT | Shelton Benjamin Unattached |
| Josh Saul NW | DEC 6-4 | A.J. Johnson EDIN |
| John Lockhart ILL | DEC 3-1 | Corey Stevenson ISU |
| John Lockhart ILL | DEC 5-2 | Bandele Adeniyi-Bada PENN |
| Brian Keck Wildcat Wrestling Club | DEC 3-1 | John Lockhart ILL |
| Randy Leydecker ASU | — | Jack Leffler CMU |
| Abe Boomer WYO | PIN 3:24 | Karl Roesler ILL |
| Wes Hand IOWA | DEC 7-3 | Abe Boomer WYO |
| Seth Charles COR | DEC 3-2 | Josh Pearce EDIN |
| Derek DelPorto SRU | MAJ DEC 9-0 | Anthony Calcagno University of Chicago |
| Derek DelPorto SRU | DEC 3-1 | Mike Russow EIU |
| Wes Hand IOWA | DEC 7-2 | Leslie Apedoe VMI |
| Matt Lamb MSU | DEC 6-4 | Kevin Keeney UO |
| Matt Lamb MSU | DEC 3-1 | Damon Davis NIU |
| A.J. Johnson EDIN | DEC 9-3 | Shawn Laughlin LEH |
| Corey Stevenson ISU | PIN 6:54 | Cedric Moore UNCG |
| John Lockhart ILL | PIN 1:04 | Josh Saul NW |
| John Lockhart ILL | DEC 3-2 | Matt Lamb MSU |
| Randy Leydecker ASU | DEC 6-4 | Mark Knauer ISU |
| Abe Boomer WYO | DEC 9-2 | Brian Criddle Cleveland State University |
| Abe Boomer WYO | DEC 3-2 | Randy Leydecker ASU |
| Josh Pearce EDIN | DEFAULT | Hercules Ward Old Timers WC |
| Anthony Calcagno University of Chicago | DEC 11-4 | Rico Jimenez San Francisco State University |
| Derek DelPorto SRU | DEC 3-0 | Seth Charles COR |
| Wes Hand IOWA | DEC 8-2 | Derek DelPorto SRU |