| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Consi 16 #2 | ||
| Alex Berman COR | 1:03 | Andy Bugajski University of Chicago |
| Roger Chandler Dave Schultz WC | — | Hyman Scott STAN |
| Joe Henson NEB | DEC 9-4 | Ryan Berger ILL |
| Mendoza | DEC 7-2 | Kevin Maier EDIN |
| Daniel Seder MICH | DEC 7-0 | J.R. Scott NW |
| Jeremy Hardman CMU | DEC 11-9 | Derek Jenkins RIDER |
| Karl Nadolsky MSU | DEC 9-7 | Max Odom HARV |
| Jon Gough | DEC 5-0 | Jason Lawrence EIU |
| Lyle Cronk | DEC 13-11 | Aaron Gilson UNC |
| Adam Webb BUCK | MAJ DEC 8-0 | Alex Carter |
| Martine Apodaca | DEC 6-3 | Adam Britt VMI |
| Dave Jordan | FORFEIT | Malik Elliot SRU |