| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| Joel Flaggert Unattached1st | PIN 0:15 | Dave Herrera Unattached2nd |
| Medal Round | ||
| Clay Kehrer Unattached3rd | DEC 9-2 | Matt Juncal Unattached4th |
| Sean Tyus SIUE5th | DEC 11-5 | Aaron Mays Unattached6th |
| Consi Semi | ||
| Matt Juncal Unattached | DEC 3-2 | Sean Tyus SIUE |
| Clay Kehrer Unattached | PIN 1:55 | Aaron Mays Unattached |
| Semifinal | ||
| Dave Herrera Unattached | DEC 7-2 | Sean Tyus SIUE |
| Joel Flaggert Unattached | DEC 11-4 | Clay Kehrer Unattached |
| Consi 4 | ||
| Matt Juncal Unattached | TF 16-0 | Julio Lopez Unattached |
| Aaron Mays Unattached | PIN 3:56 | Jason Sherko EIU |
| Consi 8 #2 | ||
| Matt Juncal Unattached | PIN 1:10 | Dirk Dierken University of the Cumberlands |
| Julio Lopez Unattached | DEC 3-1 | Tommy Fullerton Unattached |
| Jason Sherko EIU | PIN 3:07 | John Horman Unattached |
| Aaron Mays Unattached | PIN 1:39 | Brandon Phillips Unattached |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Sean Tyus SIUE | DEC 9-6 | Brandon Phillips Unattached |
| Dave Herrera Unattached | PIN 1:38 | Jason Sherko EIU |
| Clay Kehrer Unattached | MAJ DEC 11-1 | Julio Lopez Unattached |
| Joel Flaggert Unattached | MAJ DEC 12-4 | Matt Juncal Unattached |
| Consi 8 #1 | ||
| Dirk Dierken University of the Cumberlands | DEC 7-0 | Justin Barber Unattached |
| Tommy Fullerton Unattached | MAJ DEC 16-5 | Nick Ferrario University of the Cumberlands |
| John Horman Unattached | DEC 9-3 | Shane Gearing Unattached |
| Aaron Mays Unattached | PIN 0:28 | Ben Laux McKendree University |
| Round of 16 | ||
| Brandon Phillips Unattached | PIN 1:52 | Justin Barber Unattached |
| Sean Tyus SIUE | PIN 1:58 | Dirk Dierken University of the Cumberlands |
| Jason Sherko EIU | PIN 3:11 | Nick Ferrario University of the Cumberlands |
| Dave Herrera Unattached | DEC 8-2 | Tommy Fullerton Unattached |
| Clay Kehrer Unattached | PIN 3:20 | Shane Gearing Unattached |
| Julio Lopez Unattached | DEC 7-3 | John Horman Unattached |
| Joel Flaggert Unattached | DEC 5-3 | Aaron Mays Unattached |
| Matt Juncal Unattached | DEC 9-6 | Ben Laux McKendree University |