| Zack Esposito OKST | PIN 1:03 | Tony Catour NIU |
| Shane Cradelli Unattached | DEC 4-2 | Anton Dietzen ILL |
| Jeff Ecklof OKLA | DEC 7-6 | Josh Wooton NIU |
| Matt McIntire IND | DEC 6-3 | Ernie Spreitzer University of the Cumberlands |
| Cal Ferry ILL | DEC 5-3 | Justin Metcalfe NIU |
| Patrick Williams ASU | DEC 9-6 | Kyle Shelton OKST |
| Brian Baglio UNC | DEC 2-0 | Jesse Zeugin UCM |
| Jeremy Spates MIZZ | PIN 1:11 | JP Stanley IND |