| Chris Pendleton OKST | PIN 1:17 | Chad Watson IND |
| Thetlon Detry University of the Cumberlands | DEC 10-4 | George Kirgan NIU |
| Brady Richardson IND | PIN 5:25 | James Bunch Lindenwood University |
| E.K. Waldhaus OKLA | MAJ DEC 14-2 | Jamie Newton UCM |
| Ben Askren MIZZ | PIN 0:32 | Kiel Grese Unattached |
| Brett Barbarick UCM | DEC 6-5 | Corey Johnson Lindenwood University |
| Kenny Robertson EIU | DEC 4-2 | T.J. Hansen MIZZ |
| Pete Friedl ILL | DEC 3-1 | Brett Munson OKST |