| Eric Flincham University of the Cumberlands | PIN 5:22 | Pat DeGain IND |
| Matt Weight ILL | PIN 5:09 | Brandon Check NIU |
| Bryan Morgan EIU | DEC 6-5 | Joel Tapler OKLA |
| Rusty Blackmon OKST | TF 15-0 | Matt Harding ILL |
| Ryan Bader ASU | MAJ DEC 11-3 | Louis Puracchio ILL |
| Clint Freeman MIZZ | DEC 9-7 | Jim Kassner EIU |
| Nate Patrick Dave Schultz WC | DEC 6-2 | Josh Buuck IND |
| Jason Potter ILL | DEC 9-2 | Mike Christian OKST |