| Evan Sola UNC | PIN 1:07 | Sean Schmaltz PUR |
| Nick Vogt McKendree University | PIN 5:52 | Anthony Rodriguez Unattached |
| Amond Prater MIZZ | DEC 3-2 | Bob Howard Lindenwood University |
| Andrae Hernandez Unattached | PIN 1:12 | Ryan Klinger ILL |
| Chad Willard McKendree University | DEC 7-2 | Joe Comparin OKLA |
| Adam Rains CHAT | DEC 10-5 | Brian Dyer IND |
| Jim Fascetta Millikin University | DEC 5-1 | Tamir Middleton Lindenwood University |
| Tyler McCormick MIZZ | MAJ DEC 10-2 | Michael Hansen UCM |