| Tyron Woodley MIZZ | TF 17-1 | Tom Tajkowski Truman State University |
| Kammi Barzin Missouri Valley College | DEC 9-7 | Shaun Miller Millikin University |
| Waylon Lowe Davey Crockett | DEC 5-3 | Anthony Castillo ILL |
| Robby Gosnell ODU | DEC 5-3 | Rocky Vercher Lindenwood University |
| Donny Reynolds ILL | DEC 4-1 | Garrett Atkinson UNC |
| Tim Scarl IND | DEC 3-2 | Tyler Clark WIS |
| John DeCeault PUR | PIN 1:17 | Joel Britt Missouri Valley College |
| Wes Roberts OKLA | PIN 2:44 | Chris Henry Unattached |