| Finals |
| Nate Gallick ISU1st | DEC 5-3 | Andy Simmons MSU2nd |
| Medal Round |
| C.J. Ettelson UNI3rd | DEC 11-7 | Josh Wooton NIU4th |
| Brandon Carter CMU5th | FORFEIT | Eric Kruger CMU6th |
| Dustin Hinschberger Wartburg7th | DEC 3-2 | Thad Benton PITT-J8th |
| Consi Semi |
| Josh Wooton NIU | DEC 4-2 | Eric Kruger CMU |
| C.J. Ettelson UNI | PIN 0:29 | Brandon Carter CMU |
| Semifinal |
| Nate Gallick ISU | DEC 3-0 | Brandon Carter CMU |
| Andy Simmons MSU | DEC 4-3 | Eric Kruger CMU |
| Consi 4 |
| Josh Wooton NIU | PIN 2:52 | Dustin Hinschberger Wartburg |
| C.J. Ettelson UNI | DEC 13-6 | Thad Benton PITT-J |
| Consi 8 #2 |
| Matt Schumm CSUB | DEC 10-6 | Ryan McMurray AUG-IL |
| Alex Tsirtsis IOWA | MAJ DEC 9-1 | Joey Whitaker Boston University |
| Cassio Pero ILL | DEC 7-2 | Tim Hammer MSU |
| Willie Hilton UNCP | DEC 13-6 | Mike Billings Waldorf |
| Josh Wooton NIU | MAJ DEC 11-1 | Matt Schumm CSUB |
| Dustin Hinschberger Wartburg | DEC 8-3 | Alex Tsirtsis IOWA |
| C.J. Ettelson UNI | PIN 3:20 | Cassio Pero ILL |
| Thad Benton PITT-J | DEC 3-1 | Willie Hilton UNCP |
| Quarterfinal |
| Nate Gallick ISU | DEC 8-2 | Dustin Hinschberger Wartburg |
| Brandon Carter CMU | DEC 7-4 | Josh Wooton NIU |
| Eric Kruger CMU | DEC 2-1 | Thad Benton PITT-J |
| Andy Simmons MSU | DEC 6-0 | C.J. Ettelson UNI |
| Consi 8 #1 |
| Matt Schumm CSUB | FORFEIT | Ryan Osgood UNI |
| Ryan McMurray AUG-IL | DEC 8-6 | Larry Amedio AUG-IL |
| Joey Whitaker Boston University | DEC 8-4 | Casey Carrino EIU |
| Alex Tsirtsis IOWA | DEC 9-3 | Chad Hay Illini Wrestling Club |
| Tim Hammer MSU | DEC 4-2 | Mike Rohowetz Wisconsin-La Crosse |
| Cassio Pero ILL | DEC 9-3 | Jason Cook PUR |
| Willie Hilton UNCP | DEC 3-1 | Henry Kofa Lassen College |
| Mike Billings Waldorf | PIN 3:43 | Jeremy Doyle CSUB |
| Consi 16 #2 |
| Ryan McMurray AUG-IL | DEC 4-2 | Jacob Kreigbaum AF |
| Chad Hay Illini Wrestling Club | DEC 6-1 | Andrew Bribriesco University of Chicago |
| Mike Rohowetz Wisconsin-La Crosse | DEC 11-9 | Mike Hurley Cleveland State University |
| Jason Cook PUR | TF 15-0 | Chirs Kelly MacMurray College |
| Mike Billings Waldorf | DEC 9-7 | Brian Pitts Adams State |
| Round of 16 |
| Nate Gallick ISU | TF 22-5 | Jeremy Doyle CSUB |
| Dustin Hinschberger Wartburg | DEC 6-2 | Willie Hilton UNCP |
| Brandon Carter CMU | DEC 7-2 | Cassio Pero ILL |
| Josh Wooton NIU | DEC 5-2 | Tim Hammer MSU |
| Eric Kruger CMU | DEC 4-3 | Alex Tsirtsis IOWA |
| Thad Benton PITT-J | DEC 7-1 | Casey Carrino EIU |
| C.J. Ettelson UNI | MAJ DEC 12-3 | Larry Amedio AUG-IL |
| Andy Simmons MSU | MAJ DEC 12-2 | Matt Schumm CSUB |
| Round of 32 |
| Nate Gallick ISU | PIN 5:27 | Ryan Osgood UNI |
| Willie Hilton UNCP | DEC 9-3 | Ryan McMurray AUG-IL |
| Dustin Hinschberger Wartburg | DEC 4-0 | Jacob Kreigbaum AF |
| Cassio Pero ILL | DEC 9-3 | Joey Whitaker Boston University |
| Tim Hammer MSU | DEC 10-6 | Andrew Bribriesco University of Chicago |
| Josh Wooton NIU | DEC 8-4 | Chad Hay Illini Wrestling Club |
| Alex Tsirtsis IOWA | MAJ DEC 16-5 | Mike Hurley Cleveland State University |
| Eric Kruger CMU | DEC 4-1 | Mike Rohowetz Wisconsin-La Crosse |
| Casey Carrino EIU | DEC 2-0 | Chirs Kelly MacMurray College |
