| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Consi 16 #1 | ||
| Nick Ramirez WYO | DEC 6-5 | Joe Coughlin GMU |
| Tanner Gardner STAN | DEC 7-2 | Mark Moos MICH |
| Cory Fish BSU | DEC 5-0 | Daren Hockett Western Colorado University |
| Jamie Hernandez CSUF | DEC 11-4 | Pierre Bondoc San Francisco State University |
| Brandon Kinney COLU | DEC 3-1 | Trevor Charbonneau University of Nebraska at Kearney |
| Brandon Kinney COLU | DEC 9-5 | Jeff Hedges UNCG |
| Jeff Hedges UNCG | DEC 3-2 | Brandon Kinney COLU |
| Jeff Hedges UNCG | DEC 6-5 | Mike Rodriguez COR |
| John Olanowski MIZZ | DEC 9-7 | Jeff Hedges UNCG |
| Matt Eveleth PENN | DEC 3-2 | Pat Castillo NIU |
| Jeff Hedges UNCG | DEC 6-5 | Mike Wilding Western Wyoming Community College |
| Mike Wilding Western Wyoming Community College | DEC 10-7 | DeSean Willis Cumberland University |
| Will Livingston OSU | PIN 3:17 | Tyler Sim CIT |
| Pat Castillo NIU | DEC 4-2 | John Olanowski MIZZ |
| Will Livingston OSU | DEC 11-9 | Mark Johnston Dickinson State |
| Chad Sportelli KENT | DEC 7-2 | Will Livingston OSU |
| Chad Sportelli KENT | DEC 11-4 | Tyler Bowles ASU |
| Pat Castillo NIU | — | Chad Sportelli KENT |
| Tyler Bowles ASU | DEC 9-4 | Greg Einfrank BRWN |
| Tyler Bowles ASU | DEC 7-3 | Zach Valdez AF |