| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Consi 16 #1 | ||
| Joseph Sheffield UNCG | MAJ DEC 14-3 | Chris Kennedy Mesa State |
| Thor Moen ASU | DEC 3-2 | Jed Wade COLU |
| Jon May NEB | PIN 1:59 | Mark Ellis MIZZ |
| Jeff Burdorf NIU | PIN 0:33 | Eric Rogers CHAT |
| Ryan Kittrick GMU | DEC 3-2 | Jason Still WYO |
| Vincent Bordi San Francisco State University | MAJ DEC 14-3 | Eric Large Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University |
| Brandon Rupp Western Wyoming Community College | PIN 2:25 | Andrew Skinner Western Colorado University |
| Dustin Rogers WVU | DEC 9-4 | Ben Reiter PENN |
| Ben Reiter PENN | DEC 9-3 | Joe Ellwood OHIO |
| Ben Reiter PENN | DEC 3-2 | Xavier Taylor Cumberland University |
| Dustin Rogers WVU | DEC 3-2 | Andy Patrick BSU |
| Xavier Taylor Cumberland University | PIN 1:57 | Wade Empting Missouri Valley College |
| Andy Patrick BSU | DEC 1-0 | Jordan Hein WIS |
| Jermail Porter KENT | — | Dustin Rogers WVU |
| Ty Watterson ORST | DEC 6-2 | Wade Sauer CSUF |
| Charlie Walker EMU | DEC 6-4 | Tony Stegman AF |
| Jordan Hein WIS | DEC 3-2 | Charlie Walker EMU |
| Jordan Hein WIS | PIN 1:15 | Nick Ciufo RIDER |
| Scott Smith Jeff Schossow | DEC 7-3 | Jeff Parker BUFF |
| Wade Sauer CSUF | DEC 5-0 | Jermail Porter KENT |
| Levon Mock BRWN | DEC 3-2 | Joe Espejo Dickinson State |
| Scott Smith Jeff Schossow | DEC 7-2 | Levon Mock BRWN |
| Zach Hammond COR | DEC 5-2 | Scott Smith Jeff Schossow |
| Zach Hammond COR | DEC 5-3 | David Morgan CSUB |
| Wade Sauer CSUF | MAJ DEC 10-0 | Zach Hammond COR |
| Broc Maffia UCD | PIN 4:08 | Scott Smith Jeff Schossow |
| David Morgan CSUB | DEC 10-4 | Broc Maffia UCD |
| David Morgan CSUB | — | Anthony Turchetta UVU |