| Round of 32 |
| Anthony Williams EIU | DEC 9-5 | Collin Allgire McKendree University |
| Brad Gallagher UINDY | PIN 3:41 | Cody Frye Missouri Valley College |
| John Fleming UINDY | DEC 4-2 | Adam Hall Rend Lake College |
| Jake Nay Truman State University | DEC 11-7 | Justin Laflower UINDY |
| Greg Cannon OKLA | DEC 6-2 | DeSean Willis Cumberland University |
| Kazuyuki Hastimotto Truman State University | MAJ DEC 9-0 | Josh Allen UINDY |
| Nick Velliquette MIZZ | DEC 6-1 | Shannon Fowler Northwest Missouri State |
| Jimmy Nichols UINDY | DEC 3-2 | Darrin Green Meramec |
| Eric Rogers Cumberland University | PIN 4:15 | Sammy Capaleton MacMurray College |
| Gabe Flores ILL | PIN 0:25 | Donald Butler McKendree University |
| A.J. Ciccarelli EIU | DEC 5-3 | Andy McArthur Harper College |
| Steve Chico Unattached | PIN 2:59 | Ryan Nallen ILL |
| John Olanowski MIZZ | TF 17-2 | Brandon Nice Missouri Valley College |
| Scott Audo Unattached | MAJ DEC 11-1 | Blake VanSickle Unattached |
| Javier Maldonado CHAT | PIN 2:07 | Craig Addison Northwest Missouri State |
| J.R. Roman OKLA | DEC 6-4 | John Deneen ILL |
