| Finals |
| Brock Wittmeyer PENN1st | 4-1 | David Rella PSU2nd |
| Consi Semi |
| Rick Schmelyun Unattached | PIN 1:11 | Landis Wright LHU |
| Luke Manuel Unattached | 2-1 | Corey Blake Unattached |
| Semifinal |
| Keegan Mueller UNC | 10-2 | Corey Blake Unattached |
| Brock Wittmeyer PENN | 3-1 | Eric Decker VT |
| Consi 4 |
| Luke Manuel Unattached | 2-1 | Marcus Effner Cleveland State University |
| Landis Wright LHU | 9-7 | Jeff Zannetti PENN |
| Rick Schmelyun Unattached | 1-0 | Tommy Hutchinson APP |
| Corey Blake Unattached | 7-4 | Josh Evans MVILLE |
| Consi 8 #2 |
| Jeff Zannetti PENN | 5-1 | Dennis Galante Unattached |
| Luke Manuel Unattached | 3-2 | Andrey Ivanahchenko NAVY |
| Josh Evans MVILLE | PIN 2:55 | Mario Morelli Unattached |
| Quarterfinal |
| Brock Wittmeyer PENN | 14-4 | Luke Manuel Unattached |
| Marcus Effner Cleveland State University | 8-4 | Jeff Zannetti PENN |
| Eric Decker VT | PIN 2:25 | Aaron Glover DUKE |
| Keegan Mueller UNC | 7-2 | Robby Neill Unattached |
| Corey Blake Unattached | 4-3 | Tommy Hutchinson APP |
| David Rella Unattached | 3-1 | Dennis Galante Unattached |
| Consi 8 #1 |
| Luke Manuel Unattached | 1-0 | Sli Bostelman Unattached |
| Tommy Hutchinson APP | 4-3 | Dominic Ross CLAR |
| Dennis Galante Unattached | 9-5 | Chad Porter LIB |
| Josh Evans MVILLE | PIN 4:30 | David Richmond Unattached |
| Jeff Zannetti PENN | 9-3 | Aaron Glover DUKE |
| Andrey Ivanahchenko NAVY | 7-3 | Manuel Schubert LEH |
| Brent Fiorito Unattached | 4-2 | Brandon Monin Unattached |
| Consi 16 #2 |
| Mario Morelli Unattached | 6-3 | Bill Morosetti Unattached |
| David Richmond Unattached | 16-1 | Jon Drew ARMY |
| Brandon Monin Unattached | 15-0 | Nick Fastuca PITT-J |
| Sli Bostelman Unattached | 1-0 | Robby Neill Unattached |
| Chad Porter LIB | 9-0 | Nick Shafer MSU |
| Manuel Schubert LEH | 3-2 | Ed Gibbons ARMY |
| Dominic Ross CLAR | 5-2 | Jim Celi Kutztown University |
| Aaron Glover DUKE | 7-4 | Javonte Ashford King University |
| Round of 16 |
| Marcus Effner Cleveland State University | 3-2 | Mario Morelli Unattached |
| Jeff Zannetti PENN | 7-4 | Bill Morosetti Unattached |
| Keegan Mueller UNC | 10-2 | Sli Bostelman Unattached |
| Dennis Galante Unattached | PIN 0:27 | David Richmond Unattached |
| David Rella Unattached | 10-4 | Jon Drew ARMY |
| Eric Decker VT | 6-4 | Josh Evans MVILLE |
| Round of 32 |
| Jon Drew ARMY | 3-2 | Sonny Flood Kutztown University |
| David Rella Unattached | 2-1 | Kyle Keane PITT-J |
| Mario Morelli Unattached | 8-0 | Andrew Martin LHU |
| Keegan Mueller UNC | 7-0 | Kent Smith OHIO |
| Corey Blake Unattached | 7-3 | Eric Kauffman SHIP |
| Marcus Effner Cleveland State University | 5-2 | David Cox Unattached |
| Brock Wittmeyer PENN | 3-1 | Dominic Ross CLAR |
| Tommy Hutchinson APP | 1-0 | Matt Pletcher RU |
| Andrey Ivanahchenko NAVY | 4-2 | Jim Celi Kutztown University |
|
| Round of 64 |
| Jim Celi Kutztown University | 6-3 | David Quinn ARMY |
| Nick Fastuca PITT-J | 10-5 | Greg Heinz Unattached |
| Javonte Ashford King University | 17-0 | Justin Haug Unattached |
| Luke Manuel Unattached | 11-0 | Joe Troise RU |
| Rick Schmelyun Unattached | 9-0 | Brock Mantella Unattached |
| Nick Shafer MSU | 8-4 | Decota Cotton Unattached |
| Brock Wittmeyer PENN | 7-1 | Mike Lorenzo Unattached |
| Eric Decker VT | 9-6 | Derek Deutsch SHIP |
| Andrey Ivanahchenko NAVY | 6-4 | Sam Sirota |
| Round of 128 |
| Luke Manuel Unattached | 10-6 | Josh Hillard Nassau Community College |
