| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|
| True Third |
| Seth Ciasulli LEH | — | Jeff Haddad |
| True Fourth | ||
| Joe Kemmerer UNCG | — | Rick Rappo PENN |
| Finals | ||
| Mike Grey COR1st | MAJ DEC 17-7 | David Marble BUCK2nd |
| Medal Round | ||
| Joe Kemmerer UNCG3rd | FORFEIT | — |
| Rick Rappo PENN5th | FORFEIT | Jeff Haddad6th |
| Consi Semi | ||
| Rick Rappo PENN | FORFEIT | Bryan Ortenzio PENN |
| Jeff Haddad | DEC 7-3 | Billy Martin DREX |
| Semifinal | ||
| David Marble BUCK | DEFAULT | Seth Ciasulli LEH |
| Mike Grey COR | DEC 2-1 | Joe Kemmerer UNCG |
| Consi 4 | ||
| Billy Martin DREX | DEC 12-8 | Leigh Tobias BING |
| Rick Rappo PENN | PIN 1:40 | Greg Hart BUCK |
| Bryan Ortenzio PENN | DEC 6-5 | Matthew Bonson UVA |
| Jeff Haddad | DEC 3-2 | Philip Boyer PENN |
| Consi 8 #2 | ||
| Leigh Tobias BING | PIN 5:12 | Junior Amazan |
| Jeff Haddad | MAJ DEC 14-2 | Nick Kilstein |
| Matthew Bonson UVA | DEC 12-5 | Andrew Arnold East Stroudsburg University |
| Andrew Arnold East Stroudsburg University | MAJ DEC 16-8 | Dave Gilio DREX |
| Rick Rappo PENN | DEC 5-4 | Dave Gilio DREX |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Joe Kemmerer UNCG | MAJ DEC 8-0 | Philip Boyer PENN |
| Seth Ciasulli LEH | DEC 2-1 | Rick Rappo PENN |
| Mike Grey COR | MAJ DEC 17-7 | Billy Martin DREX |
| David Marble BUCK | MAJ DEC 14-5 | Bryan Ortenzio PENN |
| Consi 8 #1 | ||
| Dave Gilio DREX | PIN 1:28 | Nick Tonini SUNY-Cortland |
| Mark Bistis PENN | PIN 1:30 | Jeremiah Biddle Husky Wrestling Club |
| Jeff Haddad | TF 17-2 | Bryce Ebert Kutztown University |
| Junior Amazan | PIN 3:16 | Tyler Harmer |
| Nick Kilstein | DEC 6-4 | Robert Slavin BING |
| Leigh Tobias BING | DEC 2-1 | Anthony Jerome BING |
| Matthew Bonson UVA | TF 16-0 | Andrew Arnold East Stroudsburg University |
| Greg Hart BUCK | DEC 8-4 | Rob Vollrath Kutztown University |
| Round of 16 | ||
| Rick Rappo PENN | PIN 2:55 | Nick Kilstein |
| Bryan Ortenzio PENN | PIN 1:42 | Tyler Harmer |
| Joe Kemmerer UNCG | DEC 9-2 | Greg Hart BUCK |
| Philip Boyer PENN | MAJ DEC 13-3 | Junior Amazan |
| Billy Martin DREX | DEC 12-9 | Matthew Bonson UVA |
| Mike Grey COR | PIN 3:13 | Robert Slavin BING |
| Seth Ciasulli LEH | MAJ DEC 13-0 | Jeff Haddad |
| David Marble BUCK | MAJ DEC 20-6 | Anthony Jerome BING |
| Pigtail | ||
| Nick Kilstein | PIN 3:27 | Andrew Arnold East Stroudsburg University |
| Joe Kemmerer UNCG | DEC 5-1 | Leigh Tobias BING |
| Philip Boyer PENN | DEC 4-0 | Nick Tonini SUNY-Cortland |
| Rick Rappo PENN | PIN 4:11 | Mark Bistis PENN |
| — | PIN 4:11 | — |
| Seth Ciasulli LEH | PIN 1:00 | Bryce Ebert Kutztown University |
| Mike Grey COR | PIN 2:57 | Jeremiah Biddle Husky Wrestling Club |
| Billy Martin DREX | PIN 4:23 | Cory Woldorf UNCG |
| Anthony Jerome BING | DEC 3-2 | Rob Vollrath Kutztown University |
| Bryan Ortenzio PENN | DEC 3-2 | Dave Gilio DREX |