| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Consi 16 #1 | ||
| Dalton Jensen ISU | TF 16-0 | Jake Flynn Illinois State WC |
| Tristen DeShazer NIU | PIN 1:04 | Matt Redmond PUR |
| Drew Headlee PITT | MAJ DEC 13-1 | Alex Warren IND |
| Michael Bonora Rhode Island | DEC 5-3 | Fred Rodgers RIDER |
| Micah Carter MSU | MAJ DEC 12-3 | Mike McPeak Montana State - Northern |
| Cody Cleveland CHAT | TF 16-0 | Jacob Elsbernd Peacock WC |
| Tyrez Ash SIUE | DEC 6-4 | Josh Lehman Harper College |
| Ali Lockett San Francisco State University | FORFEIT | David Yi Unattached |
| Vince Castillo NIU | MAJ DEC 13-4 | Antonio Nicholson Cleveland State University |
| Randy Aguirre San Francisco State University | DEC 5-3 | Layne Greedy Peacock WC |
| Ben Hitchcock Olivet College | PIN 4:58 | Josh Mohr Illinois State WC |
| Vince Hannon MIZZ | PIN 1:51 | Willie Saxton MIZZ |
| C.J. Ettelson UNI | PIN 1:54 | Nick Schumate SIUE |
| Adam Keiswetter University of Nebraska at Kearney | PIN 1:39 | Tyler Nauman PITT |
| Jake Kriegbaum AF | PIN 0:56 | James Kohlberg NW |
| Garrett Drucker ORST | DEC 8-3 | Rob Yahrmarkt Olivet College |