| John Dergo ILL1st | DEC 5-1 | James Williamson MIZZ2nd |
| Medal Round | ||
| Matt Cauley Lindenwood University3rd | DEC 10-4 | Ben Friedl ILL4th |
| Nick Pullano ODU5th | DEC 6-4 | Joey Garrity MIZZ6th |
| Consi Semi | ||
| Matt Cauley Lindenwood University | TF 21-5 | Nick Pullano ODU |
| Ben Friedl ILL | DEC 4-3 | Joey Garrity MIZZ |
| Semifinal | ||
| James Williamson MIZZ | DEC 4-2 | Joey Garrity MIZZ |
| John Dergo ILL | DEC 3-1 | Matt Cauley Lindenwood University |
| Consi 4 | ||
| Nick Pullano ODU | TF 15-0 | Travis Barbarick UCM |
| Ben Friedl ILL | MAJ DEC 10-2 | John Andrews MIZZ |
| Consi 8 #2 | ||
| Nick Pullano ODU | DEC 7-0 | Chris Branam Campbellsville University |
| Travis Barbarick UCM | DEC 7-1 | Vince Demarest MIZZ |
| Ben Friedl ILL | MAJ DEC 12-0 | Ryan Sonderegger MIZZ |
| John Andrews MIZZ | DEC 7-1 | Josh Bryant McKendree University |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| James Williamson MIZZ | MAJ DEC 11-2 | Vince Demarest MIZZ |
| Joey Garrity MIZZ | DEC 6-4 | Nick Pullano ODU |
| Matt Cauley Lindenwood University | TF 22-7 | John Andrews MIZZ |
| John Dergo ILL | MAJ DEC 10-1 | Ryan Sonderegger MIZZ |
| Consi 8 #1 | ||
| Chris Branam Campbellsville University | DEC 7-5 | Kenny Meredith University of Central Oklahoma |
| Travis Barbarick UCM | DEC 5-0 | Clinton Polz ILL |
| Ben Friedl ILL | DEC 6-0 | Jesse Sheets UCM |
| Josh Bryant McKendree University | MAJ DEC 8-0 | Ben Ellard Campbellsville University |
| Consi 16 #2 | ||
| Chris Branam Campbellsville University | PIN 4:56 | Austin Haedicke Unattached |
| Travis Barbarick UCM | MAJ DEC 11-2 | Matt Burns Lindenwood University |
| Josh Bryant McKendree University | FORFEIT | Nick Hayes NW |
| Round of 16 | ||
| James Williamson MIZZ | FORFEIT | Nick Hayes NW |
| Vince Demarest MIZZ | DEC 4-1 | Ben Ellard Campbellsville University |
| Joey Garrity MIZZ | DEC 3-1 | Ben Friedl ILL |
| Nick Pullano ODU | MAJ DEC 14-2 | Jesse Sheets UCM |
| Matt Cauley Lindenwood University | MAJ DEC 19-5 | Clinton Polz ILL |
| John Andrews MIZZ | DEC 9-2 | Travis Barbarick UCM |
| Ryan Sonderegger MIZZ | DEC 4-3 | Kenny Meredith University of Central Oklahoma |
| John Dergo ILL | MAJ DEC 12-4 | Chris Branam Campbellsville University |
| Round of 32 | ||
| James Williamson MIZZ | PIN 1:28 | Austin Haedicke Unattached |
| Joey Garrity MIZZ | MAJ DEC 18-5 | Matt Burns Lindenwood University |
| John Dergo ILL | PIN 5:34 | Josh Bryant McKendree University |