| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 32 | ||
| Paul Sanford CIT | 10-0 | Dylan Dabolt BUFF |
| Mike Rodriguez COR | 9-1 | Caleb Myers King University |
| Jon Bittinger DUQ | 13-4 | Ilyass Elmsaouri Unattached |
| Pat Strizki Unattached | 5-3 | Mike Gomez Unattached |
| Allan Stein NAVY | PIN 5:05 | Tyler Mashkow Unattached |
| Clint Frutiger MSU | 4-3 | James Knox Unattached |
| Frank Perrelli COR | 8-0 | Kenneth Torres Nassau Community College |
| Mike Robinson Unattached | 7-3 | Anthony Burke UVA |
| John Erickson Unattached | 5-0 | Joe Eurell Wagner College |
| Pat Harrington Unattached | 11-3 | Scott Morgan PITT-J |
| Fernando Martinez ARMY | 10-1 | Prescott Garner Unattached |
| Lance Penhale ARMY | 4-1 | Paul Myers Unattached |
| George Ester LHU | 5-4 | Ryan Bosso PITT |
| Derrek Bosso PITT-J | 7-1 | John Sutika Unattached |
| Tony Comunale PRIN | 11-2 | Nick Hyatt Unattached |
| Ross Gitomer UVA | 6-2 | Kevin Chapman DUQ |