| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 64 | ||
| Allan Stein NAVY | 9-4 | Manny Ramirez Unattached |
| Frank Perrelli COR | 10-2 | Jeremy Adams VMI |
| John Erickson Unattached | 15-0 | Ryan Riggs Cleveland State University |
| Pat Strizki Unattached | 7-2 | Wilson Williams Unattached |
| Paul Myers Unattached | 2-0 | Eric Caschera PSU |
| Joe Eurell Wagner College | 16-0 | Nick Custodio CWPSU |
| James Knox Unattached | 15-5 | Zachary Jones Unattached |
| John Sutika Unattached | 7-4 | Tim Trivisanno Unattached |
| Clint Frutiger MSU | PIN 0:57 | Wyatt Anderson Unattached |
| Tony Comunale PRIN | 10-6 | Ed Galvin SHU |
| Kevin Chapman DUQ | 8-6 | Nick Keshecki Wagner College |
| Mike Gomez Unattached | 4-2 | Jay Adamson Unattached |
| Tyler Mashkow Unattached | 6-0 | Desmond Moore Unattached |
| Jon Bittinger DUQ | 4-3 | Tyler Sim Unattached |
| Mike Robinson Unattached | 16-1 | Mike Margherita LEH |
| Paul Sanford CIT | PIN 0:51 | Andrew Smith CLAR |
| Scott Morgan PITT-J | 7-1 | Eddie Harris Kutztown University |
| Caleb Myers King University | 7-6 | Bo Touris Unattached |