| Finals |
| Eric Albright UVA1st | 3-2 | Mike Grey COR2nd |
| Consi Semi |
| Chris Notte Nassau Community College | 12-7 | Whitt Dunning ARMY |
| Tyler Milonas Unattached | 11-7 | Matthew Bonson Unattached |
| Semifinal |
| Eric Albright UVA | 3-1 | Will Livingston Unattached |
| Mike Grey COR | 3-1 | Joe Kemmerer Unattached |
| Consi 4 |
| Chris Notte Nassau Community College | 8-2 | Brandon Reasy PITT-J |
| Matthew Bonson Unattached | PIN 2:46 | Danny Lopes UNC |
| Tyler Milonas Unattached | 8-6 | Bryan Ortenzio PENN |
| Whitt Dunning ARMY | 7-0 | Billy Ashnault Unattached |
| Consi 8 #2 |
| Billy Ashnault Unattached | 7-2 | Tyler Anthony VMI |
| Matthew Bonson Unattached | PIN 1:12 | Nick Bridge COR |
| Bryan Ortenzio PENN | PIN 3:31 | Aaron Ely Unattached |
| Brandon Reasy PITT-J | 4-3 | Abby Rush Boston University |
| Quarterfinal |
| Eric Albright UVA | 8-5 | Tyler Milonas Unattached |
| Joe Kemmerer Unattached | 2-1 | Chris Notte Nassau Community College |
| Mike Grey COR | 14-2 | Whitt Dunning ARMY |
| Consi 8 #1 |
| Abby Rush Boston University | 11-3 | Matt Pagan NAVY |
| Billy Ashnault Unattached | MED. FORFEIT | David Armstrong Unattached |
| Matthew Bonson Unattached | 13-3 | William Simpson ARMY |
| Tyler Anthony VMI | 7-6 | Tony Lascari CLAR |
| Bryan Ortenzio PENN | 5-2 | Philip Boyer PENN |
| Aaron Ely Unattached | 10-1 | Christian Smith LIB |
| Brandon Reasy PITT-J | 11-0 | Paul Hallowell CWPSU |
| Nick Bridge COR | PIN 2:13 | Michael Fenton CIT |
| Consi 16 #2 |
| Billy Ashnault Unattached | 5-2 | Ryan Goddu Boston University |
| William Simpson ARMY | 14-0 | Anthony Easter CIT |
| Christian Smith LIB | PIN 5:20 | Josh Sandoval Unattached |
| Matt Pagan NAVY | 4-2 | Rob Vollrath Kutztown University |
| Brandon Reasy PITT-J | PIN 0:16 | Josh Palivoda Cleveland State University |
| Nick Bridge COR | PIN 1:21 | Nicky Pereira PRIN |
| Tony Lascari CLAR | 8-2 | Paul Grogan RU |
| Philip Boyer PENN | PIN 3:19 | Sean Reed Unattached |
| Round of 16 |
| Danny Lopes UNC | 2-1 | Abby Rush Boston University |
| Whitt Dunning ARMY | 4-1 | Bryan Ortenzio PENN |
| Joe Kemmerer Unattached | 5-1 | Matthew Bonson Unattached |
| Eric Albright UVA | 6-2 | Tyler Anthony VMI |
| Chris Notte Nassau Community College | 10-1 | Michael Fenton CIT |
| Tyler Milonas Unattached | MED. FORFEIT | David Armstrong Unattached |
| Mike Grey COR | 13-3 | Aaron Ely Unattached |
| Round of 32 |
| Eric Albright UVA | 8-2 | Nick Bridge COR |
| Chris Notte Nassau Community College | 5-1 | Tony Lascari CLAR |
| Joe Kemmerer Unattached | 5-2 | Billy Ashnault Unattached |
| Danny Lopes UNC | 11-1 | Josh Sandoval Unattached |
| Paul Hallowell CWPSU | 5-4 | Philip Boyer PENN |
| Whitt Dunning ARMY | 12-2 | Josh Palivoda Cleveland State University |
| Bryan Ortenzio PENN | 3-1 | Brandon Reasy PITT-J |
| Aaron Ely Unattached | 4-2 | Rob Vollrath Kutztown University |
| David Armstrong Unattached | 10-8 | Anthony Easter CIT |
|
| Round of 64 |
| Paul Grogan RU | PIN 0:56 | Tyler Harmer Wagner College |
| Tony Lascari CLAR | 16-0 | Rob Diletto Unattached |
| Whitt Dunning ARMY | 6-1 | Mike Sears Unattached |
| Mike Grey COR | 17-0 | Jeff Rotella HOF |
| Josh Palivoda Cleveland State University | 13-5 | Pat Feely SHU |
| Nicky Pereira PRIN | 5-0 | Bryce Ebert Kutztown University |
| Matthew Bonson Unattached | 14-6 | Micah Carter MSU |
| Brandon Reasy PITT-J | 13-0 | John Michael SIMPSON USMAPS |
| Eric Albright UVA | 4-2 | Kyle Fluke EDIN |
| Danny Lopes |
