| Finals |
| Bubba Jenkins PSU1st | 9-3 | Mike Roberts Boston University2nd |
| Consi Semi |
| Desi Green Unattached | 5-4 | Tim Hammer MSU |
| Matt Cusick Unattached | MED. FORFEIT | Pat Riley UVA |
| Semifinal |
| Bubba Jenkins PSU | 15-3 | Eduardo Delgado Nassau Community College |
| Shawn Harris UVA | PIN 2:30 | Sean Joyce ARMY |
| Mike Roberts Boston University | 8-5 | Tim Hammer MSU |
| Consi 4 |
| Tim Hammer MSU | 4-1 | Justin Sparrow Unattached |
| Pat Riley UVA | 6-0 | Matt Rosen VT |
| Desi Green Unattached | 4-2 | Sean Joyce ARMY |
| Matt Cusick Unattached | 7-3 | Anthony Priore SHU |
| Consi 8 #2 |
| Matt Cusick Unattached | 2-0 | Kellen Bradley Unattached |
| Justin Sparrow Unattached | 10-3 | Rudy Chelednik ARMY |
| Desi Green Unattached | 4-2 | Gabriel Burak PENN |
| Matt Rosen VT | PIN 2:30 | Casey Thome ARMY |
| Quarterfinal |
| Eduardo Delgado Nassau Community College | 2-1 | Pat Riley UVA |
| Tim Hammer MSU | 6-5 | Peter Ferrara UVA |
| Sean Joyce ARMY | 8-1 | Kellen Bradley Unattached |
| Shawn Harris UVA | 7-3 | Matt Cusick Unattached |
| Mike Roberts Boston University | PIN 1:00 | Casey Thome ARMY |
| Consi 8 #1 |
| Justin Sparrow Unattached | PIN 0:30 | Brian Spangler PENN |
| Kellen Bradley Unattached | 8-6 | Jim Rafferty Army Prep |
| Desi Green Unattached | 5-2 | Zach McCray LIB |
| Matt Rosen VT | 12-6 | Peter Ferrara UVA |
| Rudy Chelednik ARMY | 10-5 | Frankie Gayeskie Unattached |
| Casey Thome ARMY | 9-1 | Matt Morgenstern Unattached |
| Gabriel Burak PENN | PIN 2:30 | Kyle O'Neill NAVY |
| Matt Cusick Unattached | 8-6 | Jeff Waruez Unattached |
| Consi 16 #2 |
| Jim Rafferty Army Prep | MED. FORFEIT | Spencer Manley NAVY |
| Desi Green Unattached | 13-6 | Patrick Larkin Wagner College |
| Matt Rosen VT | 4-1 | Andrew Flegler PITT-J |
| Frankie Gayeskie Unattached | 4-2 | Chris Davis Unattached |
| Jeff Waruez Unattached | 10-5 | Frank Croshal LEH |
| Brian Spangler PENN | PIN 3:30 | Adam Whetstone PITT-J |
| Matt Morgenstern Unattached | MED. FORFEIT | Dave Ebbott UVA |
| Kyle O'Neill NAVY | 12-0 | Will Odonnell Unattached |
| Round of 16 |
| Eduardo Delgado Nassau Community College | PIN 3:08 | Justin Sparrow Unattached |
| Anthony Priore SHU | 7-6 | Gabriel Burak PENN |
| Kellen Bradley Unattached | 5-4 | Frankie Gayeskie Unattached |
| Pat Riley UVA | 7-1 | Kyle Friedman Unattached |
| Matt Cusick Unattached | 14-9 | Adam Whetstone PITT-J |
| Peter Ferrara UVA | 4-3 | Desi Green Unattached |
| Sean Joyce ARMY | PIN 1:05 | Chris Davis Unattached |
| Tim Hammer MSU | 12-2 | Thomas Windom Unattached |
| Casey Thome ARMY | 9-6 | Kyle O'Neill NAVY |
|
| Round of 32 |
| Anthony Priore SHU | 6-4 | Dave Ebbott UVA |
| Justin Sparrow Unattached | 3-2 | Jeff Waruez Unattached |
| Chris Davis Unattached | PIN 2:30 | Shane Everett Unattached |
| Desi Green Unattached | 3-2 | Aaron Nestor Unattached |
| Gabriel Burak PENN | 7-5 | Matt Morgenstern Unattached |
| Will Odonnell Unattached | PIN 1:03 | Chris Kardos Unattached |
| Peter Ferrara UVA | PIN 2:30 | John Lester Unattached |
| Bubba Jenkins PSU | 13-5 | Matt Rosen VT |
| Eduardo Delgado Nassau Community College | PIN 0:30 | Frank Croshal LEH |
| Round of 64 |
| Frank Croshal LEH | 6-1 | Brett Perchaluk Unattached |
| Justin Sparrow Unattached | 8-2 | Matt MacLean Unattached |
| Gabriel Burak PENN | 3-2 | Joey Metzler Unattached |
| Rudy Chelednik ARMY | 4-1 | Reece Mariacher Unattached |
| Pat Riley UVA | 10-3 | Ryan McIntyre PITT-J |
| Peter Ferrara UVA | 8-2 | Jake Hunter PENN |
| Matt Morgenstern Unattached | 10-6 | Derek Royster CIT |
| Eduardo Delgado Nassau Community College | 8-2 | Vince Cina PENN |
| Jim Rafferty Army Prep | MED. FORFEIT | DJ Meagher COR |
| Will Odonnell |
| Round of 128 |
| Derek Royster CIT | PIN 3:20 | Matt Ippolito Unattached |
| Matt MacLean Unattached | 2-0 | Matt Dunn COLU |
| Joe Bockmore Unattached | 3-2 | Vince Cole VMI |
| Matt Rosen VT | 11-0 | Greg Hilbert LEH |
| Ryan McIntyre PITT-J | 5-2 | Kyle Brewer Unattached |
| DJ Meagher COR | 6-0 | Chris Chambers Kutztown University |
| Eduardo Delgado Nassau Community College | PIN 2:50 | Brad Marquart Unattached |
