| Finals |
| Rocco Caponi UVA1st | 7-2 | Dustin Kilgore Unattached2nd |
| Consi Semi |
| Chris Honeycutt Unattached | 3-2 | Matthew Ryan Unattached |
| Phil Bomberger PSU | 10-3 | Michael Moore COR |
| Semifinal |
| Dustin Kilgore Unattached | DEFAULT | Colin Hitschler PENN |
| Rocco Caponi UVA | 4-1 | Eric Chine KENT |
| Consi 4 |
| Chris Honeycutt Unattached | 2-0 | Nick Palmieri MSU |
| Phil Bomberger PSU | 5-2 | Jack Decker PSU |
| Michael Moore COR | 9-7 | Cam Simaz Unattached |
| Matthew Ryan Unattached | 10-6 | Nate Holley COR |
| Consi 8 #2 |
| Matthew Ryan Unattached | 12-3 | Russell Kropp NAVY |
| Jack Decker PSU | 4-0 | Eddie Broderick Wagner College |
| Nick Palmieri MSU | 8-3 | Shawn Fendone Unattached |
| Michael Moore COR | 10-4 | Mike Corcetti PITT-J |
| Quarterfinal |
| Rocco Caponi UVA | 9-1 | Phil Bomberger PSU |
| Colin Hitschler PENN | 6-4 | Nate Holley COR |
| Eric Chine KENT | 6-2 | Cam Simaz Unattached |
| Consi 8 #1 |
| Jack Decker PSU | PIN 5:41 | Travis Stem LHU |
| Matthew Ryan Unattached | 8-5 | Keith Dobish RU |
| Mike Corcetti PITT-J | 7-5 | Chris Daggett LIB |
| Nick Palmieri MSU | 5-1 | Ryan Malo Boston University |
| Michael Moore COR | 3-2 | Scott Cust Unattached |
| Eddie Broderick Wagner College | 7-3 | Ben Balogh Cleveland State University |
| Shawn Fendone Unattached | 3-2 | Brian Goeringer CWPSU |
| Russell Kropp NAVY | 8-5 | Andrew Silber Unattached |
| Consi 16 #2 |
| Michael Moore COR | 6-0 | Kadeem Samuels LEH |
| Travis Stem LHU | FORFEIT | Nathan Murin PITT-J |
| Keith Dobish RU | 5-1 | Mike Ward PSU |
| Ben Balogh Cleveland State University | 2-1 | Clay Steadman Unattached |
| Brian Goeringer CWPSU | MED. FORFEIT | Timothy Lutke Unattached |
| Andrew Silber Unattached | FORFEIT | Derrick Loper Delaware State University |
| Chris Daggett LIB | 19-2 | Jon Rothman HOF |
| Ryan Malo Boston University | MED. FORFEIT | Abe Cross MSU |
| Round of 16 |
| Phil Bomberger PSU | 15-9 | Matthew Ryan Unattached |
| Nate Holley COR | 4-3 | Abe Cross MSU |
| Dustin Kilgore Unattached | 10-4 | Scott Cust Unattached |
| Cam Simaz Unattached | PIN 3:46 | Nick Palmieri MSU |
| Chris Honeycutt Unattached | 11-7 | Mike Corcetti PITT-J |
| Rocco Caponi UVA | PIN 2:45 | Russell Kropp NAVY |
| Eric Chine KENT | 17-5 | Shawn Fendone Unattached |
| Colin Hitschler PENN | PIN 3:56 | Eddie Broderick Wagner College |
| Round of 32 |
| Phil Bomberger PSU | 17-1 | Jon Rothman HOF |
| Rocco Caponi UVA | 2-0 | Michael Moore COR |
| Shawn Fendone Unattached | 12-0 | Ben Balogh Cleveland State University |
| Mike Corcetti PITT-J | 7-0 | Keith Dobish RU |
| Nate Holley COR | 7-0 | Ryan Malo Boston University |
| Cam Simaz Unattached | PIN 4:44 | Nathan Murin PITT-J |
| Eric Chine KENT | 9-4 | Clay Steadman Unattached |
| Russell Kropp NAVY | 6-4 | Kadeem Samuels LEH |
| Colin Hitschler PENN | DEFAULT | Timothy Lutke Unattached |
| Matthew Ryan |
| Round of 64 |
| Travis Stem LHU | 7-5 | Carmen Rondash Boston University |
| Jack Decker PSU | 8-0 | Nick Knowles Unattached |
| Abe Cross MSU | 4-3 | Mike Pushpak COLU |
| Ryan Malo Boston University | 7-5 | Darius Caldwell |
| Keith Dobish RU | 6-0 | Jason Brown BUFF |
| Cam Simaz Unattached | PIN 3:23 | Kyle Davis Kutztown University |
| Derrick Loper Delaware State University | 20-3 | Jeff Lanier Unattached |
| Timothy Lutke Unattached | 13-4 | Garrett Gibson Unattached |
| Russell Kropp NAVY | 14-2 | Luke Culver Unattached |
|
