| Finals |
| Jon Oplinger Unattached1st | 4-2 | Joe Williams MSU2nd |
| Consi Semi |
| John Hall Boston University | 6-1 | Taylor Moore COR |
| Richard Starks ARMY | 6-2 | Michael Blackwell KENT |
| Semifinal |
| Jon Oplinger Unattached | 4-2 | Taylor Moore COR |
| Joe Williams MSU | 8-0 | Brent Jones UVA |
| Consi 4 |
| Michael Blackwell KENT | 5-2 | John Buck CIT |
| Richard Starks ARMY | 2-1 | Karim Mahmoud RU |
| Taylor Moore COR | 6-2 | Robert Johnston NAVY |
| John Hall Boston University | 7-0 | George Kocher Unattached |
| Consi 8 #2 |
| Robert Johnston NAVY | 5-2 | Matt Reck NAVY |
| John Buck CIT | 4-3 | Patrick Walsh PITT-J |
| Karim Mahmoud RU | 5-2 | Nick Parisi ARMY |
| George Kocher Unattached | 4-0 | Jason Winckel COR |
| Quarterfinal |
| Brent Jones UVA | 4-3 | Richard Starks ARMY |
| Eric Lapotsky Unattached | 3-1 | Martino Sottile Nassau Community College |
| Jon Oplinger Unattached | 8-7 | John Hall Boston University |
| Joe Williams MSU | 3-0 | Michael Blackwell KENT |
| Consi 8 #1 |
| John Buck CIT | 17-3 | Nick Sanko Unattached |
| Matt Reck NAVY | 14-5 | Jake Koshinski Unattached |
| Nick Parisi ARMY | 13-3 | Richard Vitale HOF |
| Jason Winckel COR | PIN 1:30 | James Odowd LEH |
| Patrick Walsh PITT-J | 18-2 | Mike Platco Boston University |
| George Kocher Unattached | PIN 0:47 | Jason Weber BUFF |
| Karim Mahmoud RU | 5-3 | Martino Sottile Nassau Community College |
| Robert Johnston NAVY | 2-0 | Ryan Buckner KENT |
| Consi 16 #2 |
| Matt Reck NAVY | 6-0 | Lamar Brown RU |
| Richard Vitale HOF | 8-5 | Zach Morse PRIN |
| James Odowd LEH | 7-5 | Josh White Unattached |
| Mike Platco Boston University | 20-3 | Jason Tisinger CLAR |
| Ryan Buckner KENT | 6-4 | Dave Mitchell DUQ |
| Nick Sanko Unattached | 5-2 | Mark Carnevale King University |
| Jason Weber BUFF | 10-4 | Anthony Interiano Wagner College |
| Karim Mahmoud RU | 4-2 | A.J. Hunte PITT |
| Round of 16 |
| Brent Jones UVA | PIN 1:54 | Jake Koshinski Unattached |
| Joe Williams MSU | PIN 3:27 | Jason Winckel COR |
| John Hall Boston University | PIN 1:20 | John Buck CIT |
| Eric Lapotsky Unattached | PIN 0:38 | Nick Parisi ARMY |
| Jon Oplinger Unattached | 9-2 | Patrick Walsh PITT-J |
| Round of 32 |
| Eric Lapotsky Unattached | 10-0 | Josh White Unattached |
| Patrick Walsh PITT-J | 4-0 | Matt Reck NAVY |
| John Hall Boston University | 12-0 | Ryan Buckner KENT |
| Michael Blackwell KENT | 6-4 | Karim Mahmoud RU |
| Joe Williams MSU | PIN 1:06 | Richard Vitale HOF |
| Martino Sottile Nassau Community College | 3-2 | Jason Weber BUFF |
| George Kocher Unattached | 11-3 | A.J. Hunte PITT |
| Taylor Moore COR | 10-4 | Anthony Interiano Wagner College |
| John Buck CIT | 7-5 | Dave Mitchell DUQ |
|
| Round of 64 |
| Joe Williams MSU | PIN 4:39 | Shawn Nowrey Delaware State University |
| Martino Sottile Nassau Community College | MED. FORFEIT | Scott Snyder Kutztown University |
