| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|
| Round of 16 | ||
| Walter Peppelman HARV | 2:51 | Dave Foxen BRWN |
| Andrew Swank SHU | 2:40 | Matt Ellery SHU |
| Donnie Vinson Unattached | TF 19-4 | James Baffoni BRWN |
| Pj Barch Unattached | TF 16-0 | Jeremy Adickes |
| Bobby Ward Nassau Community College | DEC 5-2 | Josh Roosa Unattached |
| Mike Roberts SHU | DEC 5-3 | Grant Daffin Unattached |
| Stephen Perez SUNY-Cortland | DEC 6-5 | Thomas Rispoli |
| Danny Scotton PRIN | MAJ DEC 12-2 | JC Bandiero Unattached |
| James Rafferty ARMY | DEC 6-1 | Frank Hickman Unattached |
| Kellen Bradley Unattached | DEC 4-2 | Paul LeBlanc SUNY-Cortland |
| Eric McGill Unattached | DEC 9-2 | Sean McCarty Unattached |
| Justin Lister BRWN | MAJ DEC 12-2 | Nick Watson |
| Ricky Bailey BRWN | DEC 8-2 | Peter Weiss Unattached |
| Nick Standish COLU | MAJ DEC 9-0 | Kevin Orchard |
| Matt Kaylor Unattached | DEC 8-3 | Derek Schreiner Unattached |