| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 32 | ||
| Dan Vallimont PSU | 16-0 | Chas Aungst Unattached |
| Matt MacLean MD | 8-3 | Joe Booth Unattached |
| Brian Tanen LEH | 3-1 | Danny Bichner Unattached |
| Jon Kaloust BING | 3-2 | Brantley Hook Unattached |
| Kyle John MD | 2-0 | Mallie Shuster Unattached |
| John Basting COR | PIN 5:40 | Travis Sheehy Unattached |
| Steve Fittery Unattached | 16-1 | Shane Everett PSU |
| Scott Winston RU | 6-3 | Corey Carlo Cleveland State University |
| Greg Zannetta RU | 9-6 | Jarrett Hostetter Unattached |
| Joel Ahern NAVY | 10-0 | Justin McCrillis Unattached |
| Gabriel Burak PENN | PIN 1:55 | Jimmy Kaden GMU |
| Frankie McLaughlin IV GMU | 5-2 | Zac Cibula Unattached |
| Glenn Shober NAVY | 6-0 | Ben Mandebraut Boston University |
| Mike Kessler RIDER | 8-2 | Nicholas Czapla Unattached |
| DJ Meagher Unattached | 12-0 | Dustin Tancredi Unattached |
| Nate Patterson BING | 4-0 | Jake Bohn GMU |