| Finals |
| Jake Strayer PSU1st | 12-4 | Joe Stanzione Unattached2nd |
| Consi Semi |
| Brad Gentzle PITT | 15-5 | Matt Bradley RIDER |
| Adam Lynch PSU | 4-0 | George Ester LHU |
| Semifinal |
| Joe Stanzione Unattached | DEFAULT | Shane Valko PITT-J |
| Jake Strayer PSU | PIN 2:49 | Denny Herndon III GMU |
| Consi 4 |
| Matt Bradley RIDER | PIN 3:56 | Lorenzo Thomas RIDER |
| Brad Gentzle PITT | 4-3 | Eric Morrill Unattached |
| George Ester LHU | 12-2 | Mike Keenan BING |
| Consi 8 #2 |
| Adam Lynch PSU | 9-3 | Robert Slavin BING |
| Lorenzo Thomas RIDER | 6-3 | Craig Montgomery Unattached |
| Brad Gentzle PITT | 6-4 | James Knox MD |
| George Ester LHU | 8-3 | Paul Grogan RU |
| Quarterfinal |
| Denny Herndon III GMU | 3-2 | Matt Bradley RIDER |
| Joe Stanzione Unattached | 9-1 | Charles Golden MD |
| Jake Strayer PSU | PIN 1:19 | Eric Morrill Unattached |
| Consi 8 #1 |
| James Knox MD | FORFEIT | Patrick Feeley Unattached |
| Paul Grogan RU | 8-6 | Bryan Pearsall Unattached |
| Lorenzo Thomas RIDER | 9-3 | Mike Rosselli Unattached |
| George Ester LHU | 9-8 | Josh Palivoda Cleveland State University |
| Brad Gentzle PITT | 5-2 | Christian Smith LIB |
| Robert Slavin BING | 4-3 | Nick Keshecki Wagner College |
| Adam Lynch PSU | 9-8 | Aaron Kalil NAVY |
| Craig Montgomery Unattached | 10-1 | Pierre Frazile CIT |
| Consi 16 #2 |
| Josh Palivoda Cleveland State University | 7-2 | Brian Bollette RU |
| Adam Lynch PSU | 8-0 | Mike Margherita Unattached |
| Craig Montgomery Unattached | PIN 0:38 | Tyler Harmer Wagner College |
| James Knox MD | 4-2 | Stephen West Unattached |
| Nick Keshecki Wagner College | PIN 2:30 | Ryan Marks Ashland University |
| Bryan Pearsall Unattached | 3-2 | Marty Borowsky PENN |
| Mike Rosselli Unattached | FORFEIT | Ed Galvin Unattached |
| Brad Gentzle PITT | 8-4 | Jack Chidester Unattached |
| Round of 16 |
| Matt Bradley RIDER | 7-5 | Robert Slavin BING |
| Joe Stanzione Unattached | 6-1 | Pierre Frazile CIT |
| Eric Morrill Unattached | 17-3 | Paul Grogan RU |
| Mike Keenan BING | MED. FORFEIT | Patrick Feeley Unattached |
| Shane Valko PITT-J | 3-0 | Christian Smith LIB |
| Jake Strayer PSU | PIN 4:22 | George Ester LHU |
| Denny Herndon III GMU | 6-4 | Aaron Kalil NAVY |
| Round of 32 |
| Joe Stanzione Unattached | PIN 6:40 | Brian Bollette RU |
| Denny Herndon III GMU | 7-5 | Brad Gentzle PITT |
| Pierre Frazile CIT | 5-3 | Josh Palivoda Cleveland State University |
| Christian Smith LIB | PIN 2:25 | Adam Lynch PSU |
| Charles Golden MD | 6-2 | Marty Borowsky PENN |
| George Ester LHU | 20-5 | Tyler Harmer Wagner College |
| Lorenzo Thomas RIDER | 15-8 | Bryan Pearsall Unattached |
| Shane Valko PITT-J | PIN 0:55 | Mike Margherita Unattached |
| Eric Morrill Unattached | 11-5 | Ed Galvin Unattached |
|
| Round of 64 |
| Jake Strayer PSU | 10-2 | Tim Haas PSU |
| Bryan Pearsall Unattached | PIN 0:49 | Austin Clouse NAVY |
