| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Consi 16 #1 | ||
| Louie DeSantis Colorado State-Pueblo | DEC 4-3 | Hayden Peterson Western Wyoming Community College |
| Trevor Machado UCD | DEC 7-2 | Kyle Francis Western Colorado University |
| Travis Sheehy UNCG | PIN 6:20 | Greg Burke WIS |
| Matt Dunn COLU | DEC 7-4 | Eric Jones WYO |
| Nikko Cataline California Baptist University | PIN 5:30 | Brantley Hooks BUCK |
| Colton Salazar PUR | PIN 1:15 | Kyle Dooley ILL |
| Andrew Stella BUFF | PIN 7:15 | Bryan Tracy BRWN |
| Justin Gaethje UNCO | FORFEIT | Steve Ross SIUE |