| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Pigtail | ||
| Ramon Santiago PRIN | PIN 6:15 | Seth Creasy Unattached |
| Joe Benedetti LHU | PIN 6:50 | Justin Loudon LHU |
| Charles Favia Stevens Institute of Technology | PIN 4:52 | Zac Cibula RIDER |
| Corey Lear Unattached | PIN 1:37 | Patrick Sullivan Unattached |
| J.P. O'Connor HARV | TF 19-3 | Joe Kyle HARV |
| Justin Lister Unattached | DEC 7-3 | Ben Mandebraut Unattached |
| Matt Dunn COLU | DEC 3-2 | Ryan McGarity Unattached |
| Ron Simchi Unattached | MAJ DEC 16-2 | Jim Schaff Unattached |
| Jesse Harrington SUNY Brockport | DEC 10-5 | Scott Sechler Unattached |
| Gabe Brotzman Unattached | DEC 6-1 | Jude Tropona BRWN |
| TJ Polacek Unattached | DEC 6-4 | Danny Scotton PRIN |
| Derek Schreiner Unattached | MAJ DEC 12-0 | Nick Brazeau Unattached |
| Daryl Cocozzo Unattached | TF 16-1 | Mike Cruse LHU |
| Bryan Tracy BRWN | DEC 6-5 | Aron Keeton BRWN |
| Aaron Keeton GMU | MAJ DEC 16-5 | Joe Mammalello Middlesex Community College |
| Thomas Rispoli Stevens Institute of Technology | MAJ DEC 12-4 | Geraldo Rodriguez Stevens Institute of Technology |