| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 64 | ||
| Eric Caschera PSU | 19-3 | Tyrus Nickoli LHU |
| Ryan Link PITT-J | PIN 1:55 | James Bak BLOOM |
| Matthew Snyder Unattached | PIN 2:57 | Lou Ruland MD |
| Brenan Lyon Unattached | 8-6 | Robert Motley CIT |
| Justin Rivera Unattached | 6-3 | Alex Moritz Unattached |
| Coltin Fought Unattached | PIN 5:43 | George Ester LHU |
| Zack Beitz Unattached | PIN 2:00 | David Baker Unattached |
| Silas Murray Nassau Community College | 5-2 | Zachory Huxford GMU |
| Dan Riggi BING | 7-4 | Andrew Spicer Penn State DuBois |
| Anthony Zanetta PITT | 15-4 | Reid Oshiro PENN |
| Brian Wright GMU | 13-1 | Justin Branham Unattached |