| Finals |
| Bryan Ortenzio PENN1st | PIN 4:01 | Nathan McCormick MIZZ2nd |
| Consi Semi |
| Filiberto Colon RIDER | 16-11 | Bryan Pearsall PSU |
| Nathan Pennesi Unattached | 5-2 | Garrett Morabito BING |
| Semifinal |
| Nathan McCormick MIZZ | MED. FORFEIT | Shane Valko PITT-J |
| Bryan Ortenzio PENN | 19-3 | Frank Cimato Unattached |
| Consi 4 |
| Filiberto Colon RIDER | 5-2 | Joey Boone Unattached |
| Nathan Pennesi Unattached | 5-4 | Jared Anongos NAVY |
| Bryan Pearsall PSU | 17-2 | Erik Galloway Unattached |
| Garrett Morabito BING | PIN 6:27 | Glenn Winslow PITT-J |
| Consi 8 #2 |
| Bryan Pearsall PSU | 15-0 | Rob Vollrath Unattached |
| Glenn Winslow PITT-J | PIN 2:22 | Zach Grove PITT |
| Jared Anongos NAVY | 5-3 | Timothy Marcoux Unattached |
| Filiberto Colon RIDER | 4-0 | Michael Fennell Unattached |
| Quarterfinal |
| Bryan Ortenzio PENN | 3-1 | Garrett Morabito BING |
| Frank Cimato Unattached | 5-3 | Nathan Pennesi Unattached |
| Nathan McCormick MIZZ | 10-1 | Erik Galloway Unattached |
| Shane Valko PITT-J | 10-5 | Joey Boone Unattached |
| Consi 8 #1 |
| Zach Grove PITT | 8-7 | Tyler Saltsman PSU |
| Bryan Pearsall PSU | DEFAULT | Cullen Isenberg Unattached |
| Timothy Marcoux Unattached | DEFAULT | Brian Benton GMU |
| Rob Vollrath Unattached | PIN 4:24 | Dan Dreibelbis Unattached |
| Jared Anongos NAVY | 9-0 | Alec Fraser Unattached |
| Filiberto Colon RIDER | PIN 1:27 | Ben Levin NAVY |
| Glenn Winslow PITT-J | PIN 1:59 | Robert Slavin BING |
| Michael Fennell Unattached | PIN 1:04 | Jeremiah Biddle BLOOM |
| Consi 16 #2 |
| Timothy Marcoux Unattached | 5-4 | Tyler Biscaha Unattached |
| Glenn Winslow PITT-J | 10-6 | Jimmy Chase BING |
| Jeremiah Biddle BLOOM | PIN 4:40 | Matt Cubillos Unattached |
| Jared Anongos NAVY | 15-0 | Jason Turpyn Unattached |
| Ben Levin NAVY | 10-4 | Mike Doria Nassau Community College |
| Zach Grove PITT | 6-4 | Casey Boyle Unattached |
| Cullen Isenberg Unattached | 6-2 | Chance Marsteller Unattached |
| Dan Dreibelbis Unattached | 9-1 | Gavin Moore Unattached |
| Round of 16 |
| Shane Valko PITT-J | DEFAULT | Brian Benton GMU |
| Bryan Ortenzio PENN | 12-2 | Rob Vollrath Unattached |
| Frank Cimato Unattached | 8-4 | Michael Fennell Unattached |
| Erik Galloway Unattached | 5-1 | Robert Slavin BING |
| Garrett Morabito BING | 7-4 | Bryan Pearsall PSU |
| Nathan McCormick MIZZ | 9-3 | Tyler Saltsman PSU |
| Nathan Pennesi Unattached | 7-4 | Filiberto Colon RIDER |
| Joey Boone Unattached | 3-0 | Alec Fraser Unattached |
| Round of 32 |
| Bryan Pearsall PSU | PIN 2:22 | Jason Turpyn Unattached |
| Alec Fraser Unattached | PIN 4:57 | Chance Marsteller Unattached |
| Tyler Saltsman PSU | 4-3 | Mike Doria Nassau Community College |
| Erik Galloway Unattached | 2-0 | Matt Cubillos Unattached |
| Nathan Pennesi Unattached | 13-3 | Zach Grove PITT |
| Rob Vollrath Unattached | 3-2 | Tyler Biscaha Unattached |
| Robert Slavin BING | 3-0 | Jeremiah Biddle BLOOM |
| Brian Benton GMU | 5-4 | Gavin Moore Unattached |
| Michael Fennell Unattached | 3-1 | Jimmy Chase BING |
|
| Round of 64 |
| Jared Anongos NAVY | 3-1 | Jordan Dix CIT |
| Matt Cubillos Unattached | 11-1 | John Hebert MSU |
| Ben Levin NAVY | 9-3 | Matthew Scherich PITT-J |
| Dan Dreibelbis Unattached | 18-7 | Jack Ingram Unattached |
| Joey Boone Unattached | 11-3 | Zach Ellis PENN |
| Glenn Winslow PITT-J | PIN 3:41 | Jordan Duckett Tiffin University |
| Casey Boyle Unattached | 11-3 | Jake Swink DUQ |
| Chance Marsteller Unattached | 6-3 | Tom Reynolds Unattached |
