| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Pigtail | ||
| Steve Bosak Unattached |
| F 2:12 |
| Zachary Moran SHU |
| Erich Smith PENN | TF 16-1 | Derek Dwyer GMU |
| Ryan Callahan PRIN | TF 16-1 | Corey Smith GMU |
| Nate Schiedel BING | F 1:37 | Jon Grecco Unattached |
| Erich Smith PENN | F 2:44 | Chris Spagnola RIDER |
| Clint Morrison RIDER | DEC 6-1 | Ryan Hembury GMU |
| Brandon Vorrius BRWN | F 0:24 | Zack Zelcs Gannon University |
| Ophir Bernstein BRWN | MAJ DEC 9-1 | Daniel Santoro PRIN |
| Ben Clymer HOF | DEC 4-2 | Clint Morrison RIDER |
| Ryan Callahan PRIN | F 4:08 | Zach Antone Niagara County Community College |
| Cameron Croy Unattached | TF 20-4 | John McArdle Middlesex Community College |
| Ophir Bernstein BRWN | F 3:34 | Jason Laboranti Unattached |
| Jon Grecco Unattached | — | Ryan Fuller Niagara County Community College |