| True Third |
| Steven Keith Unattached | DEC 7-0 | Jamie Franco HOF |
| True Fourth |
| C.J. Cobb PENN | DEC 6-5 | Chris Perez PRIN |
| Finals |
| Bryan Ortenzio PENN1st | DEC 6-1 | Justis Flamio Unattached2nd |
| Medal Round |
| Steven Keith Unattached3rd | MAJ DEC 12-1 | — |
| Chris Perez PRIN5th | MAJ DEC 15-1 | Jamie Franco HOF6th |
| Consi Semi |
| Dan Riggi Unattached | F 5:59 | Jeff Canfora PENN |
| Patrick Hunter BING | DEC 11-6 | Cody Wheeler Unattached |
| Jamie Franco HOF | DEC 2-1 | Vinny Fava RIDER |
| C.J. Cobb PENN | DEC 10-6 | Joe Stanzione Unattached |
| Semifinal |
| Justis Flamio Unattached | DEC 4-2 | Steven Keith Unattached |
| Bryan Ortenzio PENN | DEC 7-3 | Chris Perez PRIN |
| Consi 4 |
| C.J. Cobb PENN | F 5:46 | Ryan Osleeb Unattached |
| Patrick Hunter BING | DEC 10-5 | Rob Cigna Unattached |
| Vinny Fava RIDER | DEC 7-4 | Adam Weinell Gannon University |
| Jeff Canfora PENN | MAJ DEC 13-2 | Colton Perry Unattached |
| Jamie Franco HOF | DEC 4-2 | Patrick Hunter BING |
| C.J. Cobb PENN | TF 19-3 | Dan Riggi Unattached |
| Consi 8 #2 |
| Rob Cigna Unattached | DEC 9-3 | Jesse Wolfe Unattached |
| Ryan Osleeb Unattached | MAJ DEC 12-3 | Silas Murray Unattached |
| C.J. Cobb PENN | F 2:37 | Brandon Pesarchick Unattached |
| Adam Weinell Gannon University | F 1:20 | Robert Neal Unattached |
| Vinny Fava RIDER | DEC 4-2 | Andrew Polidore SHU |
| Colton Perry Unattached | DEC 7-0 | Rich Lavarato GMU |
| Patrick Hunter BING | DEC 5-3 | Joseph Gosinski Unattached |
| Jeff Canfora PENN | MAJ DEC 11-2 | Elliott Zackowski Unattached |
| Quarterfinal |
| Bryan Ortenzio PENN | MAJ DEC 9-1 | Jamie Franco HOF |
| Chris Perez PRIN | DEC 8-1 | Cody Wheeler Unattached |
| Justis Flamio Unattached | DEC 8-3 | Joe Stanzione Unattached |
| Steven Keith Unattached | DEC 6-0 | Dan Riggi Unattached |
| Consi 8 #1 |
| C.J. Cobb PENN | F 2:37 | Matt Sausman Unattached |
| Adam Weinell Gannon University | F 1:20 | Dylan Hetzer Unattached |
| Rich Lavarato GMU | TF 22-5 | Robert O'Neill Unattached |
| Elliott Zackowski Unattached | — | — |
| Patrick Hunter BING | DEC 7-5 | Zachary Isenhour GMU |
| Silas Murray Unattached | MAJ DEC 10-1 | Joshua Kennedy Unattached |
| Rob Cigna Unattached | MAJ DEC 10-2 | Brett Hernandez-Henderson Unattached |
| Round of 16 |
| Bryan Ortenzio PENN | DEC 4-2 | Brandon Pesarchick Unattached |
| Jamie Franco HOF | DEC 4-2 | Ryan Osleeb Unattached |
| Joe Stanzione Unattached | DEC 4-0 | Vinny Fava RIDER |
| Dan Riggi Unattached | DEC 2-1 | Jesse Wolfe Unattached |
| Cody Wheeler Unattached | DEC 10-3 | Jeff Canfora PENN |
| Chris Perez PRIN | MAJ DEC 12-0 | Colton Perry Unattached |
| Justis Flamio Unattached | MAJ DEC 14-3 | Robert Neal Unattached |
| Steven Keith Unattached | DEC 8-5 | Joseph Gosinski Unattached |
| Pigtail |
| Bryan Ortenzio PENN | DEC 6-2 | Patrick Hunter BING |
| Brandon Pesarchick Unattached | MAJ DEC 19-8 | Zachary Isenhour GMU |
| Jamie Franco HOF | DEC 6-1 | Rob Cigna Unattached |
| Chris Perez PRIN | F 6:42 | Andrew Polidore SHU |
| Ryan Osleeb Unattached | MAJ DEC 15-4 | Brett Hernandez-Henderson Unattached |
| Justis Flamio Unattached | TF 16-0 | Elliott Zackowski Unattached |
| Joseph Gosinski Unattached | F 6:11 | Matt Sausman Unattached |
| Steven Keith Unattached | DEC 5-2 | C.J. Cobb PENN |
| Joe Stanzione Unattached | F 1:38 | Robert O'Neill Unattached |
