| Finals |
| PJ Gillespie HOF1st | DEC 3-2 | Matt Kaylor BING2nd |
| Medal Round |
| Marshall Peppelman Unattached3rd | PIN 2:12 | Derek Schreiner Unattached4th |
| Lorenzo Thomas PENN5th | DEC 3-2 | Brandon Rolnick PRIN6th |
| Consi Semi |
| Brandon Rolnick PRIN | MAJ DEC 10-1 | Craig Scott Unattached |
| Marshall Peppelman Unattached | MAJ DEC 13-0 | James Brundage RIDER |
| Semifinal |
| PJ Gillespie HOF | DEC 4-1 | Derek Schreiner Unattached |
| Matt Kaylor BING | DEC 5-3 | Lorenzo Thomas PENN |
| Consi 4 |
| Marshall Peppelman Unattached | PIN 2:12 | Lorenzo Thomas PENN |
| Brandon Rolnick PRIN | MAJ DEC 10-0 | Rich Eva PRIN |
| James Brundage RIDER | MED FORF | Ty Knepp GMU |
| Craig Scott Unattached | DEC 2-0 | Brandon Lintner RIDER |
| Marshall Peppelman Unattached | PIN 0:37 | Zach Agostino PENN |
| Derek Schreiner Unattached | DEC 1-0 | Brandon Rolnick PRIN |
| Consi 8 #2 |
| James Brundage RIDER | DEC 6-2 | Ian Roy Unattached |
| Brandon Lintner RIDER | PIN 1:20 | Brandon Bright HOF |
| Zach Agostino PENN | DEC 6-5 | Patrick Jennings Unattached |
| Rich Eva PRIN | MAJ DEC 13-4 | Keith Stoerr Gannon University |
| Quarterfinal |
| PJ Gillespie HOF | DEC 2-1 | Marshall Peppelman Unattached |
| Matt Kaylor BING | DEC 3-2 | Craig Scott Unattached |
| Derek Schreiner Unattached | DEC 3-1 | Ty Knepp GMU |
| Lorenzo Thomas PENN | DEC 7-2 | Brandon Rolnick PRIN |
| Consi 8 #1 |
| Brandon Lintner RIDER | DEC 3-2 | Robert Blotzer Unattached |
| Brandon Bright HOF | DEC 6-5 | Jeff McElwee Unattached |
| Keith Stoerr Gannon University | PIN 6:26 | Kenton Perez Unattached |
| Patrick Jennings Unattached | MAJ DEC 12-3 | Sam Sheppard SHU |
| Rich Eva PRIN | DEC 8-4 | Frank Miele RIDER |
| Ian Roy Unattached | TF 16-0 | Patrick Sullivan Unattached |
| James Brundage RIDER | DEC 1-0 | Duke Pickett Unattached |
| Zach Agostino PENN | DEC 6-4 | Paul Saraiva Middlesex Community College |
| Round of 16 |
| Marshall Peppelman Unattached | MAJ DEC 11-0 | Rich Eva PRIN |
| Derek Schreiner Unattached | DEC 5-2 | Robert Blotzer Unattached |
| Matt Kaylor BING | MAJ DEC 13-2 | Seth Robertson GMU |
| PJ Gillespie HOF | TF 16-0 | Kenton Perez Unattached |
| Craig Scott Unattached | TF 15-0 | Patrick Sullivan Unattached |
| Pigtail |
| PJ Gillespie HOF | DEC 5-0 | James Brundage RIDER |
| Lorenzo Thomas PENN | PIN 6:55 | Brandon Bright HOF |
| Marshall Peppelman Unattached | MAJ DEC 9-0 | Ian Roy Unattached |
| Ty Knepp GMU | MAJ DEC 12-1 | Sam Sheppard SHU |
| Jeff McElwee Unattached | PIN 1:11 | — |
| Brandon Rolnick PRIN | MAJ DEC 14-3 | Brandon Lintner RIDER |
| Patrick Jennings Unattached | DEC 4-0 | Paul Saraiva Middlesex Community College |
| Craig Scott Unattached | MAJ DEC 8-0 | Frank Miele RIDER |
| Derek Schreiner Unattached | DEC 7-2 | Zach Agostino PENN |
| Duke Pickett Unattached |
