| Consi 16 #2 |
| Joel Geders Truman State University | DEC 7-1 | Jake Hare Hannibal-LaGrange University |
| Jake Gegg Lindenwood-Belleville | DEC 6-5 | Zack Wilcox Maryville University |
| Dustin Fillerton Lindenwood-Belleville | PIN | Jorcell Davis Iowa Central Community College |
| Matthew Spain Maryville University | PIN | Casey Gushleff McKendree University |
| Zach Weber McKendree University | DEC 7-4 | Lawrence Brown Independent |
| Thomas Flood IOWA | PIN | Reece Simmons Missouri Valley College |
| Morgan Denson Maryville University | DEC 9-5 | Loyde Braidlow Team Bulldog |
| Tyler Cook Hannibal-LaGrange University | FORFEIT | Nicholas Taul Missouri Valley College |
