| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 32 | ||
| Edward Ruth PSU | PIN 2:49 | Stephen West COLU |
| James Mannier NAVY | 5-2 | Andre Petroski Unattached |
| Greg Barnish LHU | PIN 6:12 | Zach Marlatt Kutztown University |
| Turtogtokh Luvsandorj CIT | 7-6 | Nick Kaczanowski MSU |
| P.J. Tasser PITT | PIN 1:13 | Frankie McLaughlin IV GMU |
| John-Martin Cannon Unattached | 9-3 | James Frascella Unattached |
| Matt Brown PSU | 14-4 | Chris Moon VT |
| Andrew Church PSU | 5-4 | Aaron McKinney LHU |
| Quinton Godley NCST | 9-3 | Vinny Waldhauser UVA |
| Owen Smith MD | 6-3 | Gary Albright NAVY |
| Stephen Doty Unattached | PIN 3:36 | Marcus Johnson ODU |
| Corey Peltier MD | 4-2 | Kevin Nash MSU |
| Robert Doyle ARMY | 3-1 | Josh Snook Unattached |
| Scott Watson Navy Prep | 9-0 | Steve Swayze GMU |
| Stephen McPeek BUCK | 8-5 | Mark Colabucci Unattached |