| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 32 | ||
| Bobby Blankenship Cleveland State University | PIN 2:58 | Connor Coyle Navy Prep |
| Alex Najjar Boston University | 7-5 | Matthew Snook MD |
| Travis Mallo Army Prep | 8-2 | Nick Mills COLU |
| Luke Johnson CIT | 14-3 | Warren Bosch Unattached |
| Caleb Gerl Unattached | 9-3 | Wil Brown ARMY |
| Tony Gardner Unattached | 11-2 | Derek Dwyer GMU |
| John Duane CIT | PIN 0:49 | Randall Howard Cleveland State University |
| Cole Baxter Unattached | 11-1 | Rob Fitzgerald MD |
| Andy Vaughan PITT | 10-2 | Michael Labell Unattached |
| Quentin Wright PSU | PIN 4:58 | Giovanni Ortiz Kutztown University |
| John Bolich Unattached | PIN 1:40 | Nick Milano CLAR |
| John Rizqallah MSU | 9-0 | Eric Torres Unattached |
| Steven Cressley CLAR | DQ | Chris Spagnola RIDER |
| John Dickson VT | 11-6 | Christopher Heald Unattached |
| Angelo Malvestuto VT | 11-8 | Matt Miller Navy Prep |