| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 64 | ||
| Cody Wheeler Unattached | 6-3 | Justin Farmer BUFF |
| Erik Galloway Unattached | PIN 1:22 | Garret Garness Unattached |
| Brian Suitor Boston University | PIN 4:32 | Anthony Michael Unattached |
| Derek Reber PSU | 13-0 | Michael Savastano Unattached |
| Evan Yenolevich Kutztown University | 15-0 | Bob Hauser BUCK |
| Joseph Gosinski Unattached | 4-1 | Hunter Wood ARMY |
| Geoffrey Alexander MD | 8-0 | Dan Riggi Unattached |
| Mike Carlone Unattached | PIN 5:49 | Colton Perry Unattached |