| Joey Trizzino IOWA | PIN | Derek Massey Iowa Western Community College |
| Ross Grande NEB | PIN | Joe Brewster SDSU |
| Aaron Sorenson ISU | MAJ DEC 11-0 | Kevin Caruso SDSU |
| Wesley Richard MINN | PIN | Joseph Winkler Iowa Central Community College |
| Tel Todd Minnesota State University, Mankato | MAJ DEC 10-2 | Boimah Karmo Iowa Western Community College |
| Devin Geoghegan Iowa Central Community College | PIN | Zach Simpson Ellsworth Community College |
| Mike Moreno Ellsworth Community College | PIN | Stu Gillmor IOWA |
| Michael Perez Iowa Central Community College | FORFEIT | Derek Hahn Minnesota State University, Mankato |