| Consi 16 #2 |
| Josh Hunter Ashland University | DEC 4-1 | Zach Case Alma College |
| Gideon Van Hook IND | DEC 6-0 | Gabe Bartok Rend Lake College |
| Eddie Sanders Mount St. Joseph | TF 19-4 | Bobby Montney Grand Valley State |
| Robert Mason Ashland University | DEC 8-4 | Darrell Pampkin Rend Lake College |
| Joey Montney Grand Valley State | FORFEIT | Colin Burandt Muskegon Community College |
| Anthony Ayres Notre Dame College | MAJ DEC 11-1 | Tyler Dempsey Grand Valley State |
| Vinny Punzone Notre Dame College | PIN | Tyler McCoy Tiffin University |
| James Jenkins Notre Dame College | DEC 9-3 | JJ McCaffrey Cleveland State University |
| Joey Montney Grand Valley State | DEC 4-3 | Cameron Maldonado Unattached |
| Gideon Van Hook IND | DEC 6-4 | Casey Jones SUNY Brockport |
