| Round of 32 |
| Tyler Foley Alma College | FORFEIT | Todd Melick Mott Community College |
| Novric Reese Indiana Institute of Technology | MAJ DEC 8-0 | Kyle Ferguson Tiffin University |
| Kristopher McKinley Indiana Institute of Technology | DEC 8-2 | Trevor Wright Unattached |
| Alonzo Shepherd IND | PIN | Eric Tokarski Olivet College |
| Garth Yenter MSU | TF 18-2 | Robert Veda Cleveland State University |
| Hermilo Esquivel MSU | MAJ DEC 12-4 | Stephen Ireland Notre Dame College |
| Cory Lester MICH | MAJ DEC 14-4 | Jon Edwards IND |
| Casimer Strzynski Alma College | DEC 5-2 | Johnny Maurice Ashland University |
| C.J. Whitten Indiana Institute of Technology | MAJ DEC 9-1 | Eddie Noble Mount St. Joseph |
| Ian Ross Lake Erie College | TF 18-0 | Joe Stolp Grand Valley State |
| Mitch Hrnyak CMU | DEC 7-2 | Ignace Hakizimana Lincoln College |
| Max Byrd Ashland University | DEC 12-10 | Ali Ayache Alma College |
| Alexander Calandrino EMU | PIN | Michael November Lake Erie College |
| Braun Marquez NIU | MAJ DEC 8-0 | Daniel Rodgers Lincoln College |
| Brett Yarbrough Indiana Institute of Technology | DEC 9-3 | Jordan Shoemaker Tiffin University |
