| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| James Fleming CLAR1st | DEC 4-2 | Frank Hickman BLOOM2nd |
| Medal Round |
| Donnie Tasser PITT3rd | DEC 6-2 | Casey Fuller EDIN4th |
| Dominic Prezzia WVU5th | DEC 2-0 | Aaron Fry LHU6th |
| Consi Semi | ||
| Donnie Tasser PITT | DEC 7-5 | Aaron Fry LHU |
| Casey Fuller EDIN | PIN 5:30 | Dominic Prezzia WVU |
| Semifinal | ||
| James Fleming CLAR | PIN 4:38 | Casey Fuller EDIN |
| Frank Hickman BLOOM | MAJ DEC 14-6 | Donnie Tasser PITT |
| Consi 4 | ||
| Aaron Fry LHU | DEC 8-6 | Brandon Sommers Cleveland State University |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| James Fleming CLAR | TF 16-0 | Brandon Sommers Cleveland State University |
| Casey Fuller EDIN | DEC 4-1 | Aaron Fry LHU |
| Donnie Tasser PITT | MAJ DEC 10-2 | Dominic Prezzia WVU |
| Frank Hickman BLOOM | TF 18-1 | Dominic Prezzia WVU |